Is the bright orange bag on the shelf really delivering the “yum-o” nutrition your dog deserves, or is it just clever marketing wrapped around so-so ingredients? As fresh-food trends and boutique brands flood the pet aisle, Rachael Ray’s Nutrish line keeps wagging its tail in the spotlight—promising celebrity-chef flair at grocery-store prices. Before you tip the bag into your pup’s bowl, it pays to know which components actually fuel lean muscle, shiny coats, and resilient immune systems…and which ones simply pad the label.
In this 2025 nutritionist’s deep-dive, we’ll microscopically examine the ten most controversial, celebrated, and misunderstood ingredients found across the Nutrish spectrum. You’ll learn how to read the fine print like a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, spot red-flag fillers, and decide whether celebrity-branded kibble aligns with your dog’s unique life stage, activity level, and medical history. No rankings, no “best-of” lists—just unbiased, science-backed intel so you can pour with confidence.
Top 10 Rachel Ray Dog Food Ingredients List
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Nutrish Real Beef, Pea & Brown Rice Recipe Whole Health Blend Dry Dog Food, 14 lb. Bag, Packaging May Vary (Rachael Ray)
Overview: Rachael Ray Nutrish Real Beef, Pea & Brown Rice Recipe delivers complete nutrition for adult dogs in a 14-pound bag. This formula positions real beef as the primary ingredient, promising lean muscle support and healthy organ function. The brand’s rebranding from Rachael Ray Nutrish to simply Nutrish maintains the same recipes while continuing their charitable mission.
What Makes It Stand Out: The Whole Health Blend concept targets three key areas: active mind, healthy body, and balanced energy. Real beef leads the ingredient list rather than fillers or by-products. Every purchase supports animals in need through The Rachael Ray Foundation, adding a feel-good factor to your dog food shopping.
Value for Money: At $1.43 per pound, this sits comfortably in the mid-range category. The 14-pound size offers good value for multi-dog households or larger breeds. The charitable donation component adds intangible value beyond the product itself.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros include real beef as the first ingredient, no artificial preservatives, and added taurine for heart health. The formula suits all breed sizes. Cons include potential grain sensitivities from brown rice, some dogs may find peas less digestible, and the packaging variation might confuse loyal customers.
Bottom Line: This solid mid-tier option works well for budget-conscious owners wanting quality ingredients. The charitable aspect and real beef foundation make it worth trying, especially for dogs without grain sensitivities.
2. Rachael Ray Nutrish Natural Premium Wet Dog Food, Savory Favorites Variety Pack, 8 Ounce Tub (Pack of 6) (6303230800)
Overview: The Rachael Ray Nutrish Savory Favorites Variety Pack offers wet food convenience in six 8-ounce tubs. This variety pack aims to provide mealtime excitement with different flavors while maintaining the brand’s natural ingredient philosophy.
What Makes It Stand Out: The variety format prevents mealtime boredom and helps identify flavor preferences. The 8-ounce size works well for small to medium dogs or as meal toppers. Wet food typically offers higher moisture content than dry kibble, supporting hydration.
Value for Money: Without a listed price, value assessment remains challenging. Generally, Nutrish wet foods position themselves as affordable premium options. The six-pack format provides convenience but may cost more per serving than dry alternatives.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros include variety that keeps dogs interested, convenient tub packaging, and the brand’s commitment to natural ingredients. Wet food often appeals to picky eaters and senior dogs with dental issues. Cons include shorter shelf life after opening, potentially higher cost per meal than dry food, and storage requirements.
Bottom Line: This variety pack suits owners wanting to add wet food to their dog’s diet or identify favorite flavors. The convenience factor and natural ingredients make it worth considering, though price comparison with competitors remains essential.
3. Nutrish Rachael Ray Gentle Digestion Variety Pack Wet Dog Food, 13 oz. Cans, 12 Count
Overview: Nutrish Gentle Digestion Variety Pack addresses sensitive stomachs with twelve 13-ounce cans featuring pumpkin, chicken, salmon, and lamb. The pack splits between smooth pâté and chunky gravy textures, offering options for different preferences while maintaining digestive health focus.
What Makes It Stand Out: The gentle digestion formula specifically targets dogs with sensitive stomachs using pumpkin as a natural digestive aid. The variety includes both pâté and chunks in gravy, accommodating texture preferences. Real veggie pieces add visual appeal and nutritional value.
Value for Money: At $0.18 per ounce ($28.69 total), this positions as premium wet food. The 13-ounce cans provide generous portions for medium to large dogs, potentially stretching to 24 meals for smaller breeds. The specialized formula justifies the higher price point for dogs with digestive issues.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros include digestive-friendly ingredients, visible vegetables, no artificial additives, and texture variety. The charitable foundation support continues. Cons include higher cost than standard wet foods, potential waste for small dogs, and the strong pumpkin scent might deter some dogs.
Bottom Line: Excellent choice for dogs with digestive sensitivities. The variety pack allows finding the perfect match while the gentle formula reduces tummy troubles. Worth the premium for dogs needing digestive support.
4. Rachael Ray Nutrish Just 6 Natural Dry Dog Food, Limited Ingredient, Lamb Meal & Rice, 6 Lbs
Overview: Nutrish Just 6 Limited Ingredient formula simplifies dog nutrition with only six main components. Lamb meal leads the recipe, making it ideal for dogs with common protein allergies. This 6-pound bag targets owners seeking minimal, recognizable ingredients.
What Makes It Stand Out: The limited ingredient approach reduces allergy risks and simplifies ingredient tracking. Lamb meal as the primary protein offers an alternative to common chicken or beef allergies. The smaller 6-pound size allows testing without commitment to large quantities.
Value for Money: At $1.69 per pound, this costs slightly more than the regular Nutrish formulas. The limited ingredient premium makes sense for dogs with sensitivities. The smaller bag size works for single-dog households or trial periods.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros include limited ingredients for allergy management, no poultry by-products, USA cooking standards, and lamb meal concentration. The formula suits sensitive dogs well. Cons include higher cost per pound, smaller bag size means more frequent purchases, and some dogs might find lamb meal less palatable than fresh meats.
Bottom Line: Perfect for dogs with food sensitivities or owners wanting ingredient simplicity. The premium pricing reflects the specialized formula. Highly recommended for allergy-prone dogs despite the higher cost.
5. Rachael Ray Nutrish Premium Natural Dry Dog Food, Real Beef & Brown Rice Recipe, 6 Pounds, Pack of 1
Overview: Nutrish Real Beef & Brown Rice Recipe offers the brand’s classic formula in a convenient 6-pound size. U.S. farm-raised beef leads the ingredient list, supported by natural prebiotics for digestive health. This smaller package suits single-dog households or those wanting to try the brand.
What Makes It Stand Out: The emphasis on U.S. farm-raised beef appeals to quality-conscious consumers. Natural prebiotics support digestive health without artificial additives. The formula excludes common fillers like wheat and poultry by-products while maintaining affordability.
Value for Money: At $1.66 per pound, this matches the pricing of comparable formulas. The 6-pound size offers good value for small breeds or trial periods without the storage challenges of larger bags. The ingredient quality justifies the mid-range pricing.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros include USA-raised beef, digestive support through prebiotics, no artificial preservatives, and wheat-free formula. The smaller bag size reduces waste risk. Cons include brown rice might not suit grain-sensitive dogs, the 6-pound size requires frequent repurchasing for larger dogs, and limited protein variety in this specific formula.
Bottom Line: Solid choice for small to medium dogs or first-time Nutrish buyers. The digestive support and quality beef make it worth the slightly higher price than budget brands. Good starting point for exploring the Nutrish line.
6. Nutrish Rachael Ray Dish Dry Dog Food Beef & Brown Rice Recipe with Veggie & Fruit Blend, 23 lb. Bag
Overview: Nutrish Rachael Ray Dish Dry Dog Food Beef & Brown Rice Recipe delivers a hearty, farm-to-bowl experience in a 23-pound bag. This adult formula showcases visible chunks of real beef, carrots, peas, and apples, promising a meal that looks as wholesome as it sounds.
What Makes It Stand Out: The “you-can-see-it” ingredient philosophy sets this kibble apart; each scoop reveals identifiable veggie and fruit pieces rather than uniform brown bits. The Rachael Ray Foundation donation adds a feel-good halo, turning every bowl into a micro-donation to shelter pets.
Value for Money: At $2.22 per pound, it sits just above mid-range grocery brands yet undercuts premium boutique labels. Given the absence of corn, wheat, soy, or poultry by-product meal, the price feels fair for a recipe that reads like a Sunday stew.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: Real beef leads the ingredient list; visible produce encourages picky eaters; 23 lb size lasts multi-dog households.
Cons: Kibble is slightly higher in calories—watch portions for less-active dogs; some bags arrive with more crushed carrots than intact pieces.
Bottom Line: If you want a recognizable-ingredient diet without the boutique price, this beef-centric recipe earns a permanent spot in the pantry.
7. Nutrish Salmon Dry Dog Food, 26 Pound Bag
Overview: Nutrish Salmon Dry Dog Food offers a 26-pound payload of ocean-sourced protein paired with brown rice and garden veggies. Designed for adult dogs of all breeds, the formula leans on salmon as the single animal protein to support lean muscle and a glossy coat.
What Makes It Stand Out: Salmon-first recipes are still rare at this volume and price point. The guaranteed omega-3 and -6 levels act like an internal conditioner, making it a go-to for owners fighting dull coats or itchy skin.
Value for Money: $1.60 per pound undercuts most fish-based competitors by 20–30%. With 26 lbs in the bag, the cost-per-feeding drops even lower for large-breed households.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: Single-source fish protein reduces allergy risk; natural preservatives keep the bag fresh for 18 months; foundation donation included.
Cons: Strong salmon aroma can linger in small kitchens; kibble size may be too petite for giant breeds, encouraging inhalation rather than chewing.
Bottom Line: A budget-friendly way to put seaside nutrition on the menu—ideal for skin-sensitive dogs and penny-wise shoppers alike.
8. Nutrish Grain Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Dog Food, 11.5 lb. Bag, Packaging May Vary (Rachael Ray)
Overview: Nutrish Grain-Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe scales down to an 11.5-pound bag while scaling up the super-food factor. Salmon still rules the ingredient list, but sweet potato steps in as the digestible carb source, creating a gluten-free, grain-free option suitable for puppies through seniors.
What Makes It Stand Out: The absence of both grains and poultry by-product meal makes this a “clean” recipe for dogs with multiple sensitivities. Sweet potato adds natural fiber that firms stools without the glycemic spike of white potatoes.
Value for Money: Price was listed as N/A at review time, but historical data hovers around $2.90/lb—premium territory. The smaller bag offsets sticker shock for trial feeds or toy-breed owners who can’t finish 25 lbs before staling.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: Ultra-digestible for itchy, yeasty dogs; resealable liner keeps kibble ocean-fresh; taurine inclusion supports cardiac health.
Cons: Smallest bag in the Nutrish line, so cost-per-pound is highest; calorie-dense—measure carefully to avoid weight creep.
Bottom Line: A niche, grain-free ace up your sleeve when vets suspect food-related skin flare-ups; worth the splurge for targeted relief.
9. Nutrish Rachael Ray Peak Protein Adventure Pack Variety Wet Dog Food, High Protein, Grain Free, 9-3.5 oz. Cups, 2 Count
Overview: The Nutrish Peak Protein Adventure Pack brings the trail to the bowl with eighteen 3.5-ounce cups of high-protein, grain-free wet food. The lineup rotates through Southern Wetlands, Wild Ridge, and Open Range recipes, each swimming in a savory gravy that turns mealtime into a wilderness expedition.
What Makes It Stand Out: Cup packaging eliminates the half-used-can dilemma—tear, serve, done. The triple-flavor variety keeps picky eaters guessing while delivering 9-10% crude protein per recipe, rivaling many dry foods in moisture-rich form.
Value for Money: $0.40 per ounce positions these cups below boutique refrigerated rolls but above grocery-store cans. Buying in bulk 18-pack shaves roughly 15% versus single-cup pricing.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: No artificial flavors or meat by-products; gravy aids hydration; perfect kibble topper for finicky seniors.
Cons: 3.5 oz size is tiny for dogs over 60 lbs—plan on 3-4 cups per meal; tear-off lids can squirt gravy if you’re not careful.
Bottom Line: A convenient, protein-packed palatability booster; stock the variety pack and watch even the most jaded tail wag.
10. Nutrish Real Chicken & Veggies Recipe Whole Health Blend Dry Dog Food, 14 lb. Bag, Packaging May Vary (Rachael Ray)
Overview: Nutrish Real Chicken & Veggies Recipe Whole Health Blend balances mind, body, and energy in a 14-pound bag aimed at small through large adult dogs. Real chicken headlines the recipe, supported by a curated blend of veggies and targeted micronutrients for overall vitality.
What Makes It Stand Out: The “Whole Health Blend” badge signals added l-carnitine and DHA—unusual extras at this price tier—promoting cognitive sharpness and fat metabolism. It’s essentially a budget-friendly spin on premium “all-life-stages” formulas without the puppy price bump.
Value for Money: $1.43 per pound lands squarely in grocery-aisle territory while delivering boutique-style supplements. The 14-pound size is Goldilocks for apartments and single-dog homes that can’t burn through 25 lbs before the fat oxidizes.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: Kibble size suits jaws from Chihuahua to Labrador; resealable Velcro strip actually stays shut; chicken fat is naturally preserved mixed tocopherols.
Cons: Contains rice and oatmeal—avoid if you’re grain-free purist; protein level (25%) may be modest for very active sporting dogs.
Bottom Line: A sensible middle-ground diet that sneaks show-ring nutrients into an everyday budget; perfect for the average active companion.
Why Ingredient Transparency Matters More Than Ever
Pet food recalls, supply-chain disruptions, and TikTok-fueled ingredient witch-hunts have turned savvy owners into label detectives. When you understand exactly what each ingredient does inside your dog’s body, you can dodge inflammatory triggers, balance micronutrients, and stretch your kibble budget without compromising quality.
How We Evaluated Each Nutrish Component
Our criteria mirror the 2025 AAFCO Canine Nutrition Guidelines: biological value, nutrient density, digestibility score, inflammatory potential, sourcing transparency, and documented safety studies. We cross-referenced independent lab data, peer-reviewed journals, and veterinary nutritionist roundtables to keep celebrity hype out of the equation.
Real Chicken vs. Chicken Meal: What’s Actually in the Scoop?
“Real chicken” sounds Instagram-worthy, but it arrives at the plant as wet muscle tissue—70 % water. Chicken meal is the same tissue rendered down to 10 % moisture, concentrating protein and minerals. Translation: pound-for-pound, meal delivers more amino acids per cup of kibble, while fresh chicken may shrink in weight after processing. The ideal? Seeing both listed—fresh for palatability, meal for density.
Beef & Poultry By-Product Meals: Nutrition Powerhouse or Waste Disposal?
By-products are not horns and hooves; they’re clean viscera, necks, and organ meats—nature’s multivitamin. The key is specified sourcing (“chicken by-product meal” vs. generic “poultry”). Organs provide heme iron, taurine, and vitamin A in forms dogs readily absorb. Concern arises when manufacturers swap species batch-to-batch, risking allergen roulette.
Brown Rice, Brewers Rice & Rice Bran: The Grain Quality Spectrum
Brown rice offers B-vitamins and fiber, brewers rice is the fragmented polishings left after beer brewing (lower fiber, quick energy), and rice bran is the fatty outer layer rich in antioxidants but prone to rancidity. Nutrish often layers all three to balance texture, glycemic load, and cost. For most dogs, this triad is benign; for grain-sensitive pups, it’s cumulative starch overload.
Peas, Lentils & Chickpeas: Functional Fibers or Stealth Fillers?
Legumes bump protein percentages on the guaranteed analysis without adding more expensive animal tissue. They also feed beneficial gut bacteria, creating short-chain fatty acids that nourish colon cells. The caveat: ongoing FDA dilated-cardiomyopathy investigations continue to eye legume-heavy diets. Until the verdict is final, moderation and rotation are prudent.
Dried Beet Pulp: Prebiotic Gold or Sugar-Slicked Waste?
This fibrous residue from sugar-beet processing is a favorite among nutritionists for its dual solubility: part feeds microbiota, part firms stools. Critics slam the “sugar” legacy, but residual sucrose is <5 %. Dogs with insulin resistance still warrant monitoring, yet for the majority, beet pulp is colon comfort food.
Chicken Fat & Fish Oil: Omega Balance Decoded
Chicken fat supplies tasty linoleic acid for skin barrier function, while menhaden fish oil brings EPA/DHA for neural and anti-inflammatory support. The ratio matters: too much omega-6 without omega-3 can fan dermatitis and joint pain. Nutrish typically keeps the omega-6:3 ratio between 5:1 and 8:1—acceptable for maintenance, but arthritic or allergy-prone dogs may need supplemental anchovy oil.
Natural Flavor, Salt & Yeast Culture: Palatability or Pandora’s Box?
“Natural flavor” is often hydrolyzed poultry liver spray-dried onto kibbles—safe, but a potential trigger for dogs with severe chicken allergies. Salt levels hover around 0.3 %, well below the 0.6 % maximum for healthy dogs. Yeast culture supplies B-vitamins and glutamic acid, enhancing umami taste without MSG backlash.
Dried Plain Beet Pulp vs. Dried Beet Pulp: A Labeling Loophole
AAFCO allows both terms, yet “plain” guarantees no added molasses. If your diabetic spaniel needs tight glycemic control, scan for the word “plain” to avoid hidden sugar spikes. It’s a single-word differential that can sway post-prandial glucose curves by 15–20 mg/dL.
Chelated Minerals: Absorption Game-Changer or Marketing Hype?
Zinc proteinate, iron glycine, copper chelate—these amino-acid-bound minerals boast 10–30 % higher bioavailability than inorganic sulfates or oxides. For growing large-breed puppies or pregnant dams, that edge translates to stronger cartilage and higher red-cell counts. The cost bump is pennies per bag, making chelation one of the cheapest nutritional upgrades available.
Dried Chicory Root: Inulin Source or Flatulence Factory?
Inulin feeds Bifidobacteria, crowding out gas-forming Clostridia. Initial transition can cause harmless borborygmus, but after 7–10 days stools usually tighten and odor drops. Start with half-portion servings if your dog has a history of irritable bowel.
Mixed Tocopherols: Natural Preservation Explained
Vitamin E compounds from soybean or sunflower oil block lipid oxidation, extending shelf life without BHA/BHT controversy. Nutrish lists them as “mixed tocopherols” plus citric acid, a synergistic combo that keeps chicken fat stable for 18 months unopened. Store below 80 °F and reseal tightly; tocopherols degrade faster in humid climates.
Glucosamine & Chondroitin: Therapeutic Levels or Label Dressing?
Chicken meal and cartilage naturally contribute these joint builders, but supplemental addition is required to hit the 400 mg/kg glucosamine shown to improve gait in clinical trials. Nutrish formulas typically provide 200–300 mg/kg—helpful for prevention, unlikely to reverse advanced arthritis. Consider standalone chews for senior mastiffs or dysplastic retrievers.
Vitamins A, E & B-Complex: Synthetic vs. Fermentation Sources
Most kibbles fortify with retinyl acetate and dl-alpha tocopheryl acetate because natural versions degrade under extrusion heat. Nutrish adds fermentation-derived B-vitamins (riboflavin, biotin) from yeast, reducing reliance on coal-tar derivatives. If you prefer plant-sourced vitamin A, rotate in orange veggies or cod-liver oil on top of the kibble.
Carrots, Pea Starch & Cranberries: Whole-Food Antioxidant Additions
Visible carrot flakes and cranberry bits are photogenic, but their mass is <1 % of the formula—more color than cure. Still, polyphenols survive extrusion and can reduce urinary-tract inflammation in spayed females prone to recurrent infections. Think of them as micro-dosed herbal sprinkles rather than therapeutic servings.
Menhaden Fish Meal & Ocean Fish Meal: Mercury, Sustainability & Omega-3 Yield
Atlantic menhaden are short-lived filter feeders, naturally low in mercury and high in EPA/DHA. Certified fisheries use purse-seine nets with minimal by-catch. Meals contribute 0.2–0.3 % DHA in finished kibble—enough for cognitive support in puppies, but not the 0.5 % therapeutic level used in renal or cognitive-disease studies. Rotate in wild-caught sardine toppers for extra neuro-protection.
How to Transition Safely & Calculate Correct Portions
Sudden swaps invite diarrhea and picky strikes. Over 7 days, blend 25 % new to 75 % old, stepping up 25 % every 48 hours while monitoring stool quality. Use your dog’s ideal body weight—not current chonk—to calculate resting energy requirement (RER = 70 × kg^0.75). Multiply by life-stage factor (1.6 for typical adult) and subtract 10 % for weight loss. Adjust monthly; kibble bags overestimate by 15–20 % for couch-potato pups.
Red-Flag Sensitivities: Corn, Soy, Dairy & Artificial Dyes
Nutrish is proudly corn- and soy-free, eliminating two top allergens. Dairy still sneaks in via cheese-flavored treats, so lactose-intolerant dogs need cross-label scrutiny. Artificial colors (Red 40, Blue 2) are absent from the 2025 kibble lines but linger in older biscuit recipes—double-check lot codes if your vet has flagged dye-linked hyperactivity.
Cost-per-Nutrient Analysis: Are You Paying for Rachel’s Smile?
Celebrity branding adds roughly 8–12 % to the invoice versus private-label equivalents. Yet Nutrish’s inclusion of chelated minerals, probiotics, and joint support shaves off separate supplement costs that could exceed the premium. Calculate price per 1,000 kcal, not per pound, to compare apples-to-apples across brands.
Sustainability & Sourcing: Where Do the Chickens Come From?
All poultry is U.S.-sourced, crate-free barns, no added hormones (federal law prohibits hormones in poultry anyway). Beef tallow can cycle through Australian or Canadian supply during drought shortages, raising carbon footprint 0.3 kg CO₂-eq per bag. Bags themselves shifted to 30 % PCR (post-consumer recycled) plastic in 2024; full recyclable mono-layer slated for 2026.
Vet-Nutritionist Tips for Customizing Rachael Ray Diets
- Allergy suspects: Run a 6-week elimination diet using Nutrish Limited Ingredient lamb recipe, then single-protein challenge.
- Kidney warriors: Pick lower-phosphorus turkey formulas (0.9 % vs 1.2 %) and add moisture via bone broth.
- Weight managers: Swap 10 % kibble volume for steamed green beans to cut 50 kcal without hunger protests.
- Athletes: Top-dress with one sardine (25 kcal) for every 20 min of intense agility work to replenish glycogen and taurine.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Is Rachael Ray dog food grain-free?
No—most recipes contain brown rice or brewers rice; they do offer a grain-free line using peas and lentils for owners who prefer legume-based carbs. -
Can puppies eat Nutrish formulas?
Yes, provided you select bags labeled “All Life Stages” or “Puppy” and adjust portions for growth-rate targets; large-breed pups need controlled calcium ≤1.4 %. -
Why do some bags list “poultry by-product meal” while others say “chicken meal”?
By-product meal includes organ meats and cartilage, boosting natural glucosamine; chicken meal is muscle tissue only. Both are safe if species-sourced. -
Has Nutrish ever been recalled?
A voluntary 2015 recall involved elevated vitamin D in wet food; no 2023–2025 kibble recalls have been reported. -
My dog is allergic to chicken—can I still use a beef recipe?
Cross-contamination is possible on shared production lines; choose the Limited Ingredient Lamb recipe manufactured in a dedicated facility for stricter control. -
How long does an open bag stay fresh?
Seal tightly and store in a cool, dry place; use within 6 weeks for peak tocopherol potency and flavor. -
Is the fish oil sourced sustainably?
Menhaden is certified by the Marine Stewardship Council; avoid formulas dated before 2023 if MSC labeling is important to you. -
Does Nutrish add sugar or molasses?
No cane sugar; only dried beet pulp (plain) and inherent sugars in sweet potato are present—total dietary sugars <5 %. -
Can I feed Nutrish to my diabetic dog?
The glycemic load is moderate; work with your vet to measure post-prandial glucose and adjust insulin timing—some dogs need portion splitting. -
What’s the omega-6:3 ratio, and why should I care?
Nutrish averages 6:1. Ratios above 10:1 can exacerbate skin allergies; the included fish oil keeps inflammation in check for most healthy dogs, but itchy pups may still benefit toppers higher in EPA/DHA.