Shoprite Dog Treats: The 10 Best-Value Dog Treat Finds at ShopRite [2025]
If you’ve ever walked down the pet aisle at ShopRite, you already know the shelves are packed with colorful bags, boxes, and bins all promising to make your dog’s tail wag harder. But once you look past the cartoon puppies and flashy “limited-time” stickers, how do you decide which treats actually deliver the best bang for your buck—especially when every family has a different budget, breed, and dietary goal?
This guide is written for shoppers who want to stretch their grocery dollars without compromising on safety, nutrition, or tail-wagging joy. Below, you’ll learn how to decode labels, spot hidden costs, and time your purchases so the treats you bring home are both wallet-friendly and veterinarian-approved. Let’s turn your routine ShopRite run into a strategic mission for maximum canine value.
Top 10 Shoprite Dog Treats
Detailed Product Reviews
1. PetShoppe Premium Chicken Fillet Dog Treats Made in USA, Only All Natural – No Fillers, Additives or Preservatives (12 oz)
Overview: PetShoppe Premium Chicken Fillet Dog Treats deliver single-ingredient goodness in every 12-oz bag. These USA-sourced, USA-made strips contain nothing but Grade A chicken breast—no grains, fillers, or mysterious “meal” powders—so you can pronounce (and trust) every component your dog swallows.
What Makes It Stand Out: Transparency rules here. The brand publishes sourcing audits and posts third-party lab tests online, rare steps in the treat aisle. The strips stay pliable, letting you tear training-sized pieces without crumbling, yet they air-dry crisp enough to clean teeth during chew time.
Value for Money: At roughly $1.59 per ounce you’re paying boutique prices, but comparable freeze-dried chicken costs $2-plus per ounce and often ships from overseas. Factor in the resealable, moisture-lock pouch that keeps the fillets fresh for months and the cost per serving drops below high-end kibble toppers.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros—hypoallergenic, easy to portion, dogs go bonkers for the smell. Cons—premium price, strips vary in thickness so cooking times differ (occasional leathery piece), and the natural chicken scent clings to fingers.
Bottom Line: If your dog has grain sensitivities or you simply want a clean, protein-rich reward, these fillets justify the splurge. Stock up when they drop under $16; freezer-friendly bags extend value even further.
2. PetShoppe Premium Chicken Jerky Dog Treats Made in USA Only All Natural – No Fillers, Additives or Preservatives (25 oz)
3. Butcher Shop 8” Chicken & Rawhide Rolls Dog Treats (2 Pack – 20 Rolls)
4. Butcher Shop Chicken and Beef Kabobs Dog Treats (2 Pack (50 Total))
5. PetShoppe Beef Jerky Sticks Dog Treat Free of Corn, Soy, Wheat, and Gluten – Made and Sourced in The USA. (25 OZ)
6. PetShoppe Premium Chicken Jerky Dog Treats (12 oz)
Overview: PetShoppe Premium Chicken Jerky Dog Treats deliver single-ingredient chicken breast strips in a 12-ounce package marketed toward health-conscious pet parents.
What Makes It Stand Out: The treats are 100 % chicken breast—no fillers, grains, or additives—air-dried into chewy strips that can be snapped to any size. The minimalist recipe appeals to owners of dogs with food sensitivities.
Value for Money: At $26.33 per pound these rank among the priciest jerky options—almost double the cost of competitor Farmland Traditions and triple Blue Buffalo Nudges—without offering farm-source transparency or resealable packaging.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros: single protein, easy to break, strong aroma dogs crave. Cons: sky-high price-to-weight ratio, non-resealable bag that lets strips harden quickly, vague country-of-origin statement, occasional inconsistent thickness that causes over-browning.
Bottom Line: Buy only if your dog demands absolutely pure chicken and you don’t mind paying gourmet prices; otherwise look to larger PetShoppe or Farmland bags for identical goodness at lower cost.
7. PetShoppe Chicken Jerky Dog Treats, 32 oz Bag, Made with Real Chicken Breast
Overview: PetShoppe’s 32-ounce Chicken Jerky is a bulk-format version of their three-ingredient breast-meat recipe—chicken, vegetable glycerin, salt—targeting multi-dog households.
What Makes It Stand Out: The value-sized, resealable pouch keeps a 2-pound supply fresh while retaining the brand’s clean label promise: no corn, soy, artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives.
Value for Money: Cost drops to $1.09 per ounce—about 60 % cheaper than the 12-ounce Premium bag—making this one of the lowest-priced USA-made jerkies per pound.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros: economical, transparent ingredient list, satisfying crunch, stays fresh for weeks after opening. Cons: slightly saltier than single-ingredient rivals, strips vary in size, glycerin may soften texture in humid climates, bag is bulky for small kitchens.
Bottom Line: An outstanding pantry staple for trainers or owners of medium-to-large breeds; break strips into bits for small dogs and you’ll still save serious cash.
8. Farmland Traditions Dogs Love Chicken Jerky Dog Treats with Only 3 Ingredients and No Fillers, 1 Pound Bag
Overview: Farmland Traditions Chicken Jerky brings farm-to-bowl simplicity with only USA-raised chicken breast, vegetable glycerin, and salt in a 1-pound, Southern-California-produced bag.
What Makes It Stand Out: The company owns its supply chain—100 % USA farm chicken, gently air-dried in small batches—yielding a softer, low-fat jerky that tears effortlessly for training.
Value for Money: At $0.93 per ounce it undercuts every comparable USA-made breast jerky, including PetShoppe’s bulk bag, while offering superior protein-to-fat ratios.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros: single-protein safety for allergy dogs, resealable pouch, tender chew suitable seniors yet easy to portion for puppies, batch-coded for traceability. Cons: limited retail presence, faint white protein bloom can alarm first-time buyers (harmless), scent is milder so some scent-driven dogs take convincing.
Bottom Line: The best intersection of price, purity, and palatability; stock up if you spot it in stock.
9. Blue Buffalo Nudges Homestyle Natural Dog Treats, Made in the USA with Real Chicken, Peas, and Carrots, 16-oz. Bag
Overview: Blue Buffalo Nudges Homestyle recipe blends real chicken, peas, and carrots into soft, cookie-like squares baked in the USA and sold in a 16-ounce bag.
What Makes It Stand Out: Unlike plain jerkies, these veggie-fortified bites add beta-carotene and fiber while remaining free of corn, wheat, soy, and artificial preservatives—ideal for owners seeking a “complete” snack.
Value for Money: $12.98 per pound positions Nudges as the cheapest USA-made treat in the lineup, costing 20 % less than Farmland and 50 % less than PetShoppe Premium.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros: soft texture great for puppies, seniors, or training; recognizable veggie bits; resealable bag; widely available in big-box stores. Cons: lower protein (14 % min) than meat-only jerkies, added sugar for browning, squares crumble if over-handled, strong herbal smell divides humans.
Bottom Line: A nutritious, wallet-friendly everyday reward—choose it if you value softness and veggie nutrition over maximum protein.
10. Hill’s Grain Free Soft Baked Naturals, All Life Stages, Great Taste, Dog Treats, Duck & Pumpkin , 8 oz Bag
Overview: Hill’s Grain-Free Soft-Baked Naturals pair real duck with pumpkin in an 8-ounce pouch of tender, cookie-textured treats suitable for all life stages.
What Makes It Stand Out: Backed by Hill’s veterinary nutritionists and the #1 vet-recommended brand, these treats deliver novel protein for allergy-prone dogs plus digestion-friendly pumpkin in a low-calorie, soft-baked format.
Value for Money: At $17.98 per pound you pay a premium for veterinary credibility and novel protein, roughly matching PetShoppe Premium but offering softer mouthfeel and smaller serving sizes.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Pros: irresistible duck aroma, breaks into tiny pieces without crumbling, only 9 kcal/treat, gentle on sensitive stomachs, made in USA. Cons: smallest bag in the group (only 40 treats), potato and pea content reduce protein density, price per pound stings for multi-dog homes, occasional stock shortages.
Bottom Line: Worth the splurge for dogs needing novel proteins or gentle textures—otherwise rotate with cheaper jerkies to stretch your budget.
Why “Value” Means More Than Price Per Ounce
Savvy pet parents know that the cheapest sticker price can end up costing more in vet bills later. True value balances unit cost with ingredient quality, calorie density, and your dog’s unique needs. A $2.99 pouch filled with empty calories isn’t a bargain if you have to feed twice as many pieces—or if it triggers itchy skin that requires medication.
Understanding ShopRite’s Private-Label Strategy
ShopRite’s own brands source from many of the same regional manufacturers as national labels, but they cut marketing and distribution mark-ups. Learning how to read the fine print on these private-label packages often reveals comparable formulations at 20–30 % savings. Keep an eye on rotating co-pack codes; if two treats list the same manufacturer and protein source, you’re essentially getting the same recipe for less.
Timing Your Trip: Sales Cycles and Seasonal Markdowns
Most ShopRite stores reset their pet section every six to eight weeks. Markdown schedules vary by state, but the pattern is predictable: end-of-month inventory reductions, post-holiday clearance, and “back-to-school” lunchbox promotions that mysteriously include dog snacks. Ask the store manager when the next planogram change is due—that’s when overstock treats get yellow-tagged.
Ingredient Priorities: What to Emphasize and What to Avoid
Look for single-source proteins, whole-food binders like sweet potato, and natural preservatives such as mixed tocopherols. Skip anything that lists “meat and bone meal” without specifying species, as well as treats containing BHA, BHT, or artificial colors. Remember that “grain-free” is not automatically healthier; the FDA continues to investigate a potential link to dilated cardiomyopathy in certain dogs.
Calorie Density vs. Treat Frequency
A tiny training reward that’s only three calories lets you reinforce good behavior without blowing your dog’s daily allowance. Conversely, a large biscuit that packs 90 calories might consume 15 % of a small dog’s energy needs in one bite. Always check kcal per piece, not just kcal per kilogram, so you can calculate true cost per training session.
Allergen Watch-List for Sensitive Dogs
Common triggers include chicken, beef, dairy, wheat, and soy. If your pup chronically licks paws or gets ear infections, try a novel-protein option like rabbit or venison. ShopRite’s freezer section often carries frozen single-ingredient strips—watch for manager specials when the sell-by date is 90 days out; you can freeze them at home for six months without nutrient loss.
Hard Chews vs. Soft Chews: Dental Economics
Crunchy biscuits and dental sticks scrape plaque, potentially lowering future cleaning bills. Soft chews are easier to break into training morsels but stick to teeth, accelerating tartar. Rotate both types: use crunchy during the day for dental benefits and soft at night for high-value crate training.
Decoding Feeding Guidelines and Guaranteed Analysis
“Feed as a treat” is not a legal portion size. Convert the guaranteed analysis to dry-matter basis to compare protein across formats—dehydrated treats look protein-heavy until you account for moisture removal. If the label lacks a calorie statement, assume 1 g of fat equals 9 kcal and 1 g of protein or carbs equals 4 kcal; do quick napkin math before checkout.
Organic, Natural, and Human-Grade: Do the Labels Justify the Price?
“Organic” requires USDA certification of both ingredients and facility—worth paying extra if you worry about pesticide residues. “Natural” merely means no synthetic additives, a standard most ShopRite private labels already meet. “Human-grade” is marketing fluff unless the plant holds a dual FDA registration, which few budget brands do. Decide which label truly aligns with your values before absorbing the up-charge.
Shelf-Stable vs. Refrigerated: Hidden Costs of Convenience
Refrigerated treats generally contain fewer preservatives, but they also carry a $0.30–$0.50 energy cost per month in extra electricity once you open them. If you shop weekly and have fridge space, the fresher option can be worth it; if you stock up monthly, shelf-stable wins on lifetime cost.
Buying in Bulk: When Bigger Really Is Better
Club-size totes can drop the price 40 %, but only if you repackage into weekly portions and vacuum-seal. Oxygen is the enemy of fats; rancid treats will cause diarrhea and negate any savings. Invest in a $20 home sealer and divide the haul the day you buy it.
Loyalty Programs, Digital Coupons, and Stacking Tricks
ShopRite’s Price Plus card automatically loads digital pet coupons that stack with manufacturer rebates. Apps like Ibotta and Fetch often feature identical products—double-dip by scanning the same receipt. Time your purchase during a “Gas Rewards” multiplier week; a $30 pet spend can shave $0.40 per gallon off your next fill-up, effectively making the treats free.
Homemade Value: Supplementing Store-Bought with DIY
Even if you’re not a baker, dehydrating leftover chicken breast in your oven at 200 °F for two hours creates low-cost jerky that’s cheaper per gram than any commercial sku. Rotate homemade goodies with store-bought to keep your dog excited and your budget intact. Freeze portions so you always have a high-value reward on hand when company drops by.
Storage Hacks to Prevent Waste and Rancidity
Keep kibble-style biscuits in their original bag inside an airtight bin; the bag’s fat barrier is engineered to block light. For soft chews, add a 300 cc oxygen absorber and store below 70 °F. Label the date opened with masking tape—most treats go rancid within six weeks once exposed to air, long before any visible mold appears.
Red-Flag Marketing Phrases Every Shopper Should Ignore
“Vet recommended” without a specific vet’s name and credentials is unverifiable. “Premium” has no legal definition. “Made with real beef” can mean 3 % beef and 97 % filler. Train your eye to skip the front of the package and flip straight to the ingredient panel and nutritional adequacy statement.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Are ShopRite private-label dog treats safe for puppies?
Yes, provided the label states the treat is formulated for “all life stages” and you adjust portion size to the puppy’s daily calorie limit.
2. How do I know if a treat is too hard for my senior dog’s teeth?
If you can’t indent it with your thumbnail or it doesn’t break cleanly in half, it’s probably too hard—opt for softer, pliable textures instead.
3. Can I return opened treats if my dog refuses them?
Most ShopRite locations offer a “Pet Satisfaction Guarantee”; bring the receipt and at least half the product for a full refund or exchange.
4. What’s the biggest hidden cost in budget treats?
Fillers that force you to feed more pieces to feel satisfied—always compare kcal per serving, not just ounces per dollar.
5. Do grain-free treats help with skin allergies?
Only if your dog is specifically allergic to grains; switching proteins is often more effective than eliminating grains.
6. How long can I freeze ShopRite dog treats?
Up to six months for meat-based treats, three months for biscuits containing fruit or yogurt chips. Wrap in freezer paper inside a zip-top bag.
7. Is it worth buying organic for training treats?
If you train daily and feed 20–30 treats, organic reduces cumulative pesticide exposure—otherwise conventional single-ingredient meats are fine.
8. Can I use cat treats as high-value dog rewards?
Occasionally, but cat treats are richer and can trigger pancreatitis in dogs; keep them under 10 % of total daily calories.
9. Why do some treats smell like chemicals?
Oxidation of rendered fats produces aldehydes—if the odor is sharp or plastic-like, the product is rancid and should be discarded.
10. What’s the quickest in-store freshness test?
Check the “best by” date, squeeze the package to feel for excess air, and look for visible fat specks or discoloration inside the clear window.
