The fall season brings with it a host of delights: crisp air, colorful foliage, and the iconic symbol of autumn – the pumpkin. While humans enjoy pumpkin spice lattes and carving jack-o’-lanterns, our canine companions have their own way of joining in the seasonal festivities through pumpkin-inspired toys. These delightful playthings have evolved significantly over the years, with 2025 bringing forth innovative designs that combine durability, safety, and irresistible appeal for dogs of all sizes and breeds. Whether your pup is a gentle chewer or an enthusiastic destroyer, there’s a pumpkin toy that can bring them joy while supporting their natural behaviors.
What makes pumpkin dog toys so captivating to our pets? Perhaps it’s the captivating orange hue against a backdrop of greener chew options, or maybe it’s the satisfying shape that lends itself to carrying, tossing, and gnawing. Whatever the reason, these seasonal favorites have transcended their autumn origins to become year-round play staples in many homes. As we look toward the best of 2025’s offerings, understanding the features that make a truly exceptional pumpkin toy can help you select the perfect plaything for your furry friend while supporting their physical and mental well-being.
Top 10 Pumpkin Dog Toy
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Petlou, Pumpkin, 1 Count
Overview: The Petlou Pumpkin is an 8-inch plush dog toy designed to resemble a pumpkin. It’s part of the Fresh Food toy line that looks like familiar foods. This toy features embroidered details for realism, soft stuffing, and an integrated squeaker for added entertainment.
What Makes It Stand Out: Its realistic pumpkin appearance sets it apart, combining the aesthetic appeal of fall decor with canine play functionality. The plush material and embroidery create a food-like appearance without compromising safety for play.
Value for Money: Priced at $11.75, this toy is moderately priced for a single plush toy. While it doesn’t offer the variety or interactive features of some comparable products, the quality construction justifies the cost for pet owners seeking a simple, seasonal toy.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include its cute pumpkin design, reasonable durability for plush material, and engaging squeaker. Weaknesses include that it’s a basic toy without special interactive features, may not withstand heavy chewers, and offers only one type of play experience.
Bottom Line: The Petlou Pumpkin is a well-made, visually appealing toy best suited for light chewers and small to medium dogs. It’s ideal for pet owners seeking a simple seasonal toy that doesn’t break the bank. For more interactive play or heavy chewers, other options might be more appropriate.
2. FONBALLOON PARTY Hide and Seek Plush Dog Toy, 2 in 1 Crinkle Interactive Squeaky Bundle Pack, Pumpkin Toy for Small Medium Dogs, Orange
Overview: The FONBALLOON PARTY Hide and Seek Plush Dog Toy bundle offers interactive play with a crinkly coffee cup box and three squeaky pumpkins. Each pumpkin can be played with separately or hidden inside the box, which features velcro closure for hiding treats. The crinkly fabric and squeakers provide multiple sensory experiences.
What Makes It Stand Out: The most distinctive feature is the hide-and-seek functionality that combines with treat dispensing. This mental stimulation makes it stand apart from simple plush toys. The two-in-one design (box and pumpkins) offers multiple play styles with a single purchase.
Value for Money: At $18.99 for four toys (box + 3 pumpkins), the cost is reasonable at $4.75 per toy. The variety and interactive features provide good value, especially when considering the mental stimulation and entertainment time it offers.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the excellent interactive design, variety of textures and sounds (crinkle and squeak), quality construction, and treat-hiding capability. Weaknesses include the velcro closure may wear over time with heavy use, and small dogs might struggle with the larger box component.
Bottom Line: The FONBALLOON Hide and Seek bundle offers exceptional value and engagement for small to medium dogs. Its design promotes mental stimulation through treat-hiding and retrieval games, making it ideal for active or curious pets. This is one of the most interactive pumpkin toys available.
3. Pumpkin Dog Toys, Indestructible Ball, Squeaky Ball for Small, Medium & Large Breed, Soft, Interactive Dog Balls, Puppy Teething Toys, Safe Toys for Indoor Play, Puppy Toys
Overview: The Pumpkin Dog Toy Indestructible Ball is a single-ball toy designed in a festive pumpkin shape. It’s marketed as durable for all dog sizes and made with pet-safe, reinforced plush material. The ball is marketed as perfect for indoor play and as a teething toy for puppies.
What Makes It Stand Out: Despite claiming to be “indestructible,” the main selling point is its supposed durability combined with the festive seasonal design. Unlike other pumpkin toys that feature multiple parts or complex designs, this offers simplicity with durability focus.
Value for Money: At $5.99, this is the most affordable option among the pumpkin toys reviewed. However, the “indestructible” claim may be questionable depending on the dog’s chewing habits.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include its very affordable price point, lightweight design suitable for indoor play, and the seasonal pumpkin aesthetic. Significant weaknesses include the questionable indestructibility claim, lack of interactive features beyond basic chewing or fetching, and limited entertainment value compared to more complex toys.
Bottom Line: This basic pumpkin ball is best suited for budget-conscious pet owners or gentle chewers seeking a minimalistic seasonal toy. While it provides a festive touch at an excellent price point, owners should temper expectations about durability. For more engagement or chew-prone dogs, investing in a more expensive, robust toy would be advisable.
4. HGB Squeaky Halloween Dog Toys, Tough Pumpkin Dog Toys for Large Medium Small Breeds, Interactive Rope Tug of War & Boredom Relief
Overview: The HGB Squeaky Halloween Dog Toy combines a tough rope with three movable stuffed pumpkins, each containing a squeaker. This multi-component toy is designed for various play styles including tug-of-war, squeaking, and solo chewing. It’s marketed as suitable for multiple dog sizes and appropriate for seasonal fun.
What Makes It Stand Out: What distinguishes this product is its dual-functionality: it serves as both a tug-of-war toy with rope and a collection of separate squeaky toys. The combination of different materials (rope, plush, oxford cloth) offers varied textures for engaging play.
Value for Money: At $13.99, it’s competitively priced for a multi-functional toy. The combination of rope play and squeaky pumpkins provides good play variety for the price.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the variety of play options, durable construction with reinforced materials, effective squeakers, and teeth-cleaning benefit from the rope. Weaknesses include the note that it’s not for aggressive heavy chewers, which limits its usefulness for powerful chewers, and the complexity might be intimidating for some dogs.
Bottom Line: The HGB Squeaky Halloween Toy offers excellent versatility in a single product, combining rope-tugging fun with squeaky pumpkin play. Its seasonal design makes it perfect for holiday engagement. While it may not withstand the most aggressive chewers, it provides great value for moderate chewers and offers multiple ways for dogs to enjoy their playtime.
5. lilfrd Halloween Dog Toys – Pumpkin & Ghosts Squeaky Plush, Hide & Seek for Small to Large Dogs
Overview: The lilfrd Halloween Dog Toys feature a pumpkin-shaped plush with three ghost toys that can be hidden inside. With two openings on the pumpkin, pet owners can either hide the ghosts or insert treats, creating an interactive game of discovery. The toy includes three squeaky ghosts for additional stimulation.
What Makes It Stand Out: What sets this product apart is its creative Halloween theme with ghosts that can be hidden in the pumpkin. Seasonal ghost elements offer a twist on traditional pumpkin toys, while the treat-hiding function adds an element of challenge for dogs.
Value for Money: At $11.99 for the pumpkin plus three ghosts, the pricing works out to $3.00 per item, representing good value for money when considering the interactive elements and total toy count.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the creative Halloween theme, effective squeakers in the ghosts, mental stimulation through hide-and-seek play, and versatile functionality (can be used with or without treats). Weaknesses include the pumpkin opening might not be durable with very persistent dogs, and the cleaning process could be challenging given the pouch design.
Bottom Line: The lilfrd Halloween Hide & Seek Pumpkin is an excellent choice for mentally stimulating play during the Halloween season. It offers good value at approximately $3 per toy component and provides both auditory stimulation through squeakers and mental engagement through treat-hiding. This toy is particularly well-suited for curious dogs that enjoy puzzle-style activities.
6. SEIS 3 Pcs Pumpkin Dog Chew Toys Pet Squeaky Toy Halloween Plush Cat Playing Toys (3 Pcs)
Overview: The SEIS 3 Pcs Pumpkin Dog Chew Toys are Halloween-themed plush toys designed for cats and small-to-medium dogs. This three-pack includes pumpkin-shaped toys with a diameter of approximately 12cm/4.72″, each containing a BB device that creates an enticing squeaking sound when pets bite them. The festive design allows pet owners to include their furry friends in holiday celebrations.
What Makes It Stand Out: What makes these toys stand out is their Halloween-specific pumpkin design and the inclusion of three toys in one package, providing variety and ensuring pets always have access to entertainment. The BB device creates an appealing squeak that attracts pets to play, while the pumpkin shape adds seasonal fun to playtime.
Value for Money: Priced at $12.99 for three toys ($4.33 per item), this set offers budget-friendly entertainment for pets. The price point is reasonable for seasonal themed toys, especially considering the multi-pack quantity. However, the disclaimer that large dogs may destroy these quickly suggests they might not be a cost-effective option for households with aggressive chewers.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the festive Halloween design, the variety of three toys, the appealing squeak feature, and the reasonable price point. Weaknesses include durability concerns for large dogs, potential disappointment if the flattened pumpkin shape matters, and limited toy type—only pumpkin-shaped options are included.
Bottom Line: The SEIS 3 Pcs Pumpkin Dog Chew Toys offer an affordable, festive option for cat and small-to-medium dog owners seeking Halloween-themed entertainment. Their price point and variety make them attractive, but durability may be a concern for aggressive chewers. Consider these for gentle chewers who will enjoy seasonal fun, but opt for more robust options if durability is a priority.
7. LiuMelinda Dog Chew Toys for Aggressive-Chewers – Indestructible Dog Toy for Aggressive Chewer，Tough Chew Toys for Dogs （Rubber Orange-Pumpkin）
Overview: The LiuMelinda Dog Chew Toys for Aggressive-Chewers are designed specifically for power chewers, made from bite-resistant tough rubber material. This pumpkin-shaped toy features a thickened rubber design that withstands heavy chewing, with users reporting “hardly any bite marks or cracks after months of use.” The toy combines durability with a pumpkin-inspired design featuring prominent lines that help clean teeth.
What Makes It Stand Out: What sets this toy apart is its exceptional durability for aggressive chewers, constructed from food-grade natural rubber that maintains elasticity without damaging teeth. The moderate squeaker adds entertainment value without being overly loud, and the multi-function design allows it to serve as a chew toy indoors, fetch toy outdoors, or even a floating toy for water play.
Value for Money: Priced at $14.99, this chew toy represents good value for aggressive chewers who quickly destroy less durable alternatives. While single-toy purchases may seem expensive compared to multi-plush packs, longevity with power chewers makes it potentially more cost-effective over time. The multi-functionality adds further value by eliminating the need for separate toys for different activities.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include exceptional durability for aggressive chewers, food-grade safe material, multi-function versatility, and moderate squeaker volume. Weaknesses might include the higher price point compared to simpler plush toys, limited design variety (only orange pumpkin shown), and potential sizing issues for very small or very large breeds.
Bottom Line: The LiuMelinda Dog Chew Toys offer an excellent solution for owners of power-chewing pets who have struggled with destroyed toys. Its rubber construction provides exceptional durability while the pumpkin-inspired design offers seasonal appeal. At $14.99, it’s a worthwhile investment for pet owners tired of constantly replacing toys. If you have an aggressive chewer, this represents exceptional value and quality despite the higher upfront cost.
8. Rosojodg Orange Pet Toy Funny Pumpkin Chew Toys Squeak Plush Dog Cat Toy Pet Supplies Plush Toys
Overview: The Rosojodg Orange Pet Toy Funny Pumpkin Chew Toys are plush, pumpkin-shaped playthings designed for both cats and dogs. With an orange pumpkin design and built-in squeaker, these toys provide entertainment through chewing, tossing, and playing fetch. The compact size makes them ideal for small and medium-sized pets, while the sturdy construction aims to withstand regular play while maintaining their squeaking function.
What Makes It Stand Out: The standout features include the versatile nature of the toy, suitable for both cats and dogs, and its seasonal pumpkin design that adds festive fun to playtime. The compact size makes it easily portable, while the combination of chewable plush exterior and squeaker provides multiple forms of engagement. The focus on both durability and entertainment value makes it appealing for balanced pet play.
Value for Money: At $7.99 per unit, this toy occupies an affordable price point in the pet market. While it’s a single toy rather than a multi-pack, its durable construction suggests it may outlast cheaper alternatives, potentially offering better long-term value. The versatility for both cats and dogs adds to its value proposition, making it suitable for multi-pet households.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the budget-friendly price point, versatility for both cats and dogs, festive pumpkin design, and compact user-friendly size. Weaknesses may include potential durability concerns with very aggressive chewers, limited functionality compared to specialized toys (no treat-dispensing features), and the single-toy purchase without variety options.
Bottom Line: The Rosojodg Orange Pet Toy offers an affordable, versatile option for cat and small-to-medium dog owners seeking seasonal fun. Its compact size and reasonable price make it accessible to a wide range of pet owners. While not the most durable option for aggressive chewers, it provides good value for casual play and interaction. If you’re looking for an inexpensive way to add Halloween-themed entertainment to your pet’s toy collection, this pumpkin toy represents a solid choice.
9. PUPTECK Halloween Dog Squeaky Chew Toys – 3 PCS Funny Pumpkin Plush Stuffed Toys for Puppy Pet Tugging Playing
Overview: The PUPTECK Halloween Dog Squeaky Chew Toys are a three-pack of Halloween-themed plush toys designed for puppy and dog playtime. This set includes three distinct designs: a tall slim pumpkin, a short fat pumpkin, and a bone-shaped toy with rope arms designed for tugging. Each toy contains a high-quality squeaker intended to keep pets entertained, though they’re not recommended for powerful chewers.
What Makes It Stand Out: The standout feature is the variety within the three-toy set, offering different sizes and shapes to keep pets engaged with varying challenges. The rope arms on the bone-shaped toy add an interactive element for tugging play, while each toy’s unique squeaker provides consistent auditory stimulation. The Halloween-specific designs add seasonal appeal to traditional dog toy functions.
Value for Money: Priced at $13.99 for three toys ($7.00 per unit), this set offers moderate pricing for a multi-pack of themed toys. The variety provided by three different designs enhances the value proposition, offering multiple play experiences from a single purchase. However, the recommendation against use with powerful chewers may limit these toys’ lifespan for some households.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the variety of three different designs, reasonable price point for a multi-pack, tugging functionality enabled by rope arms, and quality squeakers in each toy. Weaknesses include durability concerns with powerful chewers, potential for the plush construction to deteriorate with vigorous chewing, and potential noise factor of multiple squeaky toys.
Bottom Line: The PUPTECK Halloween Dog Squeaky Chew Toys offer an affordable, varied option for pet owners seeking Halloween-themed entertainment. With three distinct designs including a tugging-enabled bone toy, this set provides multiple play experiences for most dogs (except powerful chewers). At $13.99, the variety justifies the price point for occasional holiday fun. For dogs that enjoy plush toys with squeakers and you want to include them in Halloween celebrations, this three-pack represents good value despite limited longevity for aggressive chewers.
10. ZippyPaws – Halloween Holiday Brainey Squeak Plush Dog Toy – Pumpkin
Overview: The ZippyPaws Halloween Holiday Brainey Squeak Plush Dog Toy is a uniquely designed pumpkin-shaped toy featuring a “brain” pattern for Halloween appeal. This plush toy is crafted with soft fabric that won’t damage dogs’ teeth while maintaining durability for heavy playtime. Sized appropriately for medium and large dogs, it functions as both a play toy and a comforting plush companion with a medium blaster squeaker.
What Makes It Stand Out: The distinctive brain-patterned pumpkin design sets this toy apart from traditional Halloween pet toys, offering a quirky, spooky theme. The combination of soft plush material with durable construction balances comfort with longevity, while the medium blaster squeaker provides audibly engaging sounds at a moderate volume. The exclusive noisemaker technology and carefully designed size make it specifically tailored for optimal play experience.
Value for Money: Priced at $13.45, this single toy occupies a mid-range point in the pet toy market. While more expensive than basic plush toys, the ZippyPaws brand reputation for quality and thoughtful design features justify the cost for pet owners seeking durable entertainment. The durability claims suggest it may outlast cheaper alternatives, potentially offering better long-term value despite the higher single-toy price.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the unique brain-patterned pumpkin design, durable yet soft construction, appropriate sizing for medium and large dogs, moderate-volume squeaker, and quality ZippyPaws brand assurance. Weaknesses might include the single-toy purchase (no variety pack), higher price point compared to basic options, and potential limitations for very small dogs despite the “medium and large” sizing recommendation.
Bottom Line: The ZippyPaws Halloween Holiday Brainey Squeak Plush Dog Toy offers a uniquely designed, moderately priced option for medium and large dog owners seeking Halloween-themed entertainment. Its brain-patterned design adds spooky fun to playtime while durable construction suggests longevity. At $13.45, it represents a worthwhile investment for pet owners who appreciate quality design and materials. If you have a medium or large dog and want a distinctive Halloween toy combining comfort, durability, and engaging features, this pumpkin brain toy delivers quality and seasonal appeal in one thoughtfully constructed package.
Understanding the Appeal of Pumpkin Dog Toys
The Psychology Behind Seasonal Shapes
Dogs are often drawn to toys that mimic familiar objects from their environment. The pumpkin shape, with its distinctive round form and subtle ridges, offers a unique tactile experience that many find appealing. This familiarity can make a pumpkin-shaped toy more immediately attractive to a dog than an abstract shape, potentially increasing engagement and playtime.
Color Psychology in Dog Toys
The vibrant orange of pumpkins isn’t just visually appealing to humans—it also stands out in a canine’s field of vision. While dogs primarily see in shades of blue and yellow, bright orange tones create a striking contrast against green grass or other common outdoor environments, making these toys easier for dogs to spot and retrieve.
Cultural Associations and Familiarity
Pumpkins have become deeply embedded in cultural consciousness, particularly during fall months. This familiarity can translate to a dog’s play experience, as the pumpkin shape may represent seasonal excitement or associational memories from previous play experiences during autumn months.
Benefits of Pumpkin-Shaped Toys for Dogs
Supporting Natural Chewing Instincts
Chewing is a fundamental behavior for dogs, providing both physical and mental stimulation. Pumpkin toys, often designed with varying textures and thicknesses, can satisfy these natural urges while redirecting chewing from less desirable objects like furniture or shoes.
Promoting Dental Health
Many pumpkin toys incorporate features designed to support dental hygiene. Ridges, nubs, and varying surface textures can help clean teeth and massage gums as the dog chews, reducing plaque buildup and contributing to overall oral health when used appropriately under supervision.
Mental Stimulation and Enrichment
Interactive pumpkin toys, particularly those with treat-dispensing capabilities or puzzle elements, engage a dog’s cognitive abilities. Working to extract treats or solve the puzzle provides mental exercise that can reduce boredom and associated behavioral issues.
Materials and Safety Considerations
Non-Toxic Materials to Look For
When selecting a pumpkin toy, prioritize options made from food-grade, BPA-free, or veterinary-approved materials. Natural rubber, FDA-approved plastics, and safe fabrics represent the preferred categories, with clear labeling indicating they’re free from harmful chemicals like phthalates, lead, and formaldehyde.
Identifying Safe Manufacturing Practices
Reputable brands typically undergo third-party testing to ensure safety. Look for certifications from organizations such as the FDA, CPSIA, or independent testing labs. Transparency about manufacturing processes and material sourcing is also a positive indicator of a company’s commitment to safety.
Recognizing Potential Hazards
Be aware of toys that contain small parts that could break off and become choking hazards, excessive use of dyes that might transfer to your dog’s mouth or paws, and materials that might cause allergic reactions in some dogs. Always inspect toys before giving them to your pet and discontinue use if you notice any damage.