Homemade Yogurt Dog Treats: Top 10 Frozen & Baked Yogurt Treat Recipes [2025]
Nothing says “I love you” like a cool spoonful of creamy yogurt on a scorching afternoon—except maybe watching your dog’s eyes light up when that yogurt is frozen into a paw-shaped pop or baked into a biscuit that smells better than your own dessert. Yogurt-based dog treats are surging in popularity because they check every box: inexpensive, gut-friendly, endlessly customizable, and gentle enough for sensitive stomachs. Whether you’re a meal-prep pro or a kitchen rookie, you can crank out a month’s worth of drool-worthy rewards in under an hour, using ingredients you probably already have.
Below you’ll find the complete playbook—science-backed safety tips, texture tricks, flavor pairings, and the subtle differences between frozen and baked formats—so you can whip up the freshest, healthiest yogurt treats on the block without falling down an internet rabbit hole of conflicting advice.
Top 10 Homemade Yogurt Dog Treats
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Himalayan Dog Chew Yogurt Sticks, Peanut Butter, Dog Treats With Prebiotics, Probiotics & Protein, Digestive Support, Lactose & Gluten Free, Natural Dog Treat for All Breeds, Made in America, 5 Count
Overview: Himalayan Dog Chew Yogurt Sticks blend the ancient Himalayan cheese tradition with modern digestive science, delivering a peanut-butter-flavored, yogurt-based chew that’s portion-controlled and proudly made in Washington State.
What Makes It Stand Out: The dual-action gut support—prebiotics plus probiotics—paired with the rare use of Himalayan cheese as the base creates a high-protein, low-lactose chew that even sensitive dogs can enjoy without the mess of rawhide.
Value for Money: At $28.27/lb you’re paying gourmet-cheese prices, but five 1-oz sticks last a medium dog a week and replace costlier dental chews while doubling as a probiotic supplement.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: truly limited ingredient list, no grains or soy, resealable pouch keeps sticks pliable, made in USA with ethically sourced yak/cow milk.
Cons: calorie-dense (90 kcal/stick), peanut scent is faint, sticks harden if not resealed, price can induce sticker shock.
Bottom Line: If your dog battles tummy troubles or you want a clean, long-lasting chew that pulls double duty as a digestive aid, these sticks justify the splurge; otherwise rotate with cheaper biscuits.
2. Blue Buffalo Health Bars Crunchy Dog Biscuits, Oven-baked Dog Treats Made with Natural Ingredients, Bananas & Yogurt, 16-oz Bag
Overview: Blue Buffalo Health Bars are crunchy, oven-baked biscuits that combine oatmeal, real bananas, and yogurt into a vitamin-fortified reward suitable for every breed and budget.
What Makes It Stand Out: The bakery-style crunch satisfies heavy chewers while the banana-yogurt combo delivers potassium and calcium without chicken by-products, corn, wheat, or soy—rare at this price tier.
Value for Money: $6.36 for a full pound (roughly 45 medium biscuits) clocks in under 15 ¢ per treat, making daily training or multi-dog households affordable without sacrificing “premium” claims.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: crunchy texture helps scrape tartar, resealable bag stays fresh for weeks, identifiable banana pieces, enhanced with antioxidants.
Cons: contains barley and oatmeal (not grain-free), 40 kcal per biscuit adds up for small dogs, some batches arrive overly browned.
Bottom Line: An everyday, all-around winner for owners who want a trustworthy, USA-made biscuit that’s gentle on wallets and tough on plaque—just watch the calorie count for tiny pups.
3. 2 Pcs Dog Treat Molds for Baking and Freezing – Bone & Paw Shaped Silicone Dog Treat Mold, Non-Sticking, Blue & Pink – Easy Release Design for Homemade Candies, Gingerbreads, Pudding and Jelly Sweets
Overview: This two-pack of food-grade silicone molds turns your kitchen into a doggy bakery, imprinting bone- and paw-shaped goodies that pop out effortlessly whether frozen or oven-baked.
What Makes It Stand Out: The dual-color set (blue & pink) spans –40 °F to 445 °F, so one afternoon you can freeze yogurt pupsicles and the next bake peanut-butter biscuits without swapping tools.
Value for Money: For $3.22 per mold you effectively buy an endless supply of custom treats—spend pennies on ingredients instead of dollars on boutique store-bought shapes.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: non-stick flex release, dishwasher safe, mini cavities (1-in) portion-control calories, doubles as ice cube or soap molds.
Cons: 6.9″ tray fits only 9 bones + 8 paws per batch—tedious for multi-dog homes, floppy silicone needs a sheet pan for oven stability, no recipe guide included.
Bottom Line: A must-have crafty accessory for pet parents who enjoy DIY kitchens; pair with any of the yogurts reviewed here for Instagram-worthy, wallet-friendly rewards.
4. Vitakraft Drops with Yogurt Treats for Dogs, Bite-Sized Training Snacks, 8.8 Ounce (Pack of 1)
Overview: Vitakraft Drops distill creamy yogurt flavor into pea-sized, grain-free morsels fortified with six essential vitamins, engineered for rapid-fire rewarding during training sessions.
What Makes It Stand Out: The “melt-in-mouth” texture means even toothless seniors or puppies can consume them instantly, keeping focus on you—not on crunching—while whey protein adds a probiotic punch.
Value for Money: $14.51/lb looks steep until you realize 500+ drops come in the 8.8 oz pouch; that’s under 2 ¢ per mark, cheaper than most high-value training tidbits.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: tiny size = low calorie (1.2 kcal), resealable pouch prevents drying, strong yogurt aroma rivets distracted dogs, no grains, corn, or soy.
Cons: sugar (whey) can hype up excitable pups, drops scuff easily into powder in pockets, bag weight misprinted on some lots.
Bottom Line: The go-to choice for clicker trainers, agility competitors, or anyone juggling treats in a fanny pack; just seal tightly to avoid yogurt dust at the bottom.
5. PAWUP Freeze Dried Sheep Milk Yogurt Flavor, Gentle Sheep Milk Dog Treats for Sensitive Stomachs Puppies, 2.8 oz
Overview: PAWUP Freeze-Dried Sheep Milk Yogurt treats target the most delicate digestive systems—neonatal puppies, transitioning kittens, or allergy-prone adults—using sheep milk’s naturally low-lactose, high-taurine profile.
What Makes It Stand Out: Sheep milk’s fat globules are one-third the size of cow’s milk, yielding 94 % digestibility and locking in twice the vitamin A; paired with chicken and freeze-dried at –40 °C, nutrients survive at 96 % potency.
Value for Money: At $5.35/oz you’re funding niche dairy and costly lyophilization, but one 2.8 oz bag rehydrates to nearly 8 oz of fresh food—cheaper than vet-prescribed neonatal diets.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros: single-protein transparency, gentle on IBD/renal dogs, crumbles double as meal topper, no fillers or preservatives, supports brain & eye development.
Cons: strong barnyard smell, nuggets powder easily in transit, premium price limits everyday use, bag size too small for large-breed training.
Bottom Line: A specialized, vet-worthy option for weaning babies or dogs with cow-milk intolerance; keep a bag on hand for tummy crises even if you rotate cheaper treats for routine rewards.
6. Himalayan Pet Supply Yogurt Sticks Dog Treats in 3 Flavors: 1 Bacon, 1 Yogurt & 1 Peanut Butter Flavor (3 Bags Total, 5 Sticks/Bag, 4.8 Oz Bags) Plus Shaynanigans Lid
Overview: Himalayan Pet Supply Yogurt Sticks deliver a trio of canine-approved flavors—bacon, yogurt, and peanut butter—packaged as soft-density chews fortified with pre- and probiotics. Each 4.8 oz bag contains five sticks, giving you fifteen total chews plus a bonus Shaynanigans lid for resealing.
What Makes It Stand Out: The treats double as functional supplements: live cultures support gut health while omega-rich ingredients promote skin and coat. The soft texture is gentle on puppy teeth yet satisfying for seniors, and the USA-made recipe excludes corn, wheat, soy, and artificial anything.
Value for Money: At roughly $1.60 per stick, you’re paying for digestible functionality, not just filler. The probiotic inclusion and multi-life-stage suitability help justify the premium over conventional biscuits.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – tummy-friendly cultures, three flavor rotation, no major allergens, resealable lid included.
Cons – calorie count isn’t printed per stick, bags feel half-full, price jumps quickly for multi-dog households.
Bottom Line: If your dog has a sensitive stomach or you want a chew that cleans teeth without rock-hard hardness, these sticks earn their keep. Stock up when on sale.
7. Hill’s Natural Soft Savories, All Life Stages, Great Taste, Dog Treats, Chicken & Yogurt, 8 oz Bag
Overview: Hill’s Natural Soft Savories wrap real chicken and yogurt into a soft, pillow-shaped bite sized for training or treating. The 8 oz pouch is resealable and carries the brand’s ubiquitous “#1 Veterinarian Recommended” badge.
What Makes It Stand Out: Hill’s keeps the ingredient list short—no artificial preservatives or flavors—while still achieving a moist, meaty aroma dogs notice instantly. The soft texture makes them ideal for puppies, seniors, or dogs with dental issues.
Value for Money: At under nine dollars, you’re buying veterinary brand trust without the vet-office markup. Price per pound lands mid-pack versus grocery-store biscuits, but the softer texture means less waste from crumbled leftovers.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – USA-made, vet-endorsed, easy to tear into smaller pieces, low odor for pocket training.
Cons – only one flavor variety per bag, contains some salt and sugar, not grain-free for sensitive pups.
Bottom Line: A dependable, middle-of-the-road treat that won’t upset stomachs or budgets. Keep a bag in the car and one in the treat jar—dogs never tire of the chicken-yogurt combo.
8. JADINGSFARM Freeze-Dried Dog Treats, Strawberry Yogurt with Milk,Limited Ingredient, Grain-Free, Glute-Free, High Protein Strawberry Yogurt Treats for Dogs Cats 5.7 oz
Overview: JADINGSFARM freeze-dries fresh strawberries and milk into pale pink cubes that smell like instant yogurt powder. The 5.7 oz jar yields light, airy bites that can be served whole, crumbled over kibble, or rehydrated into a pink slurry.
What Makes It Stand Out: Limited-ingredient transparency—literally two foods—meets advanced freeze-drying that locks in probiotics without preservatives. The result is a grain-free, gluten-free, high-calcium snack cats and dogs both accept.
Value for Money: At $2.81 per ounce you’re paying artisanal-coffee prices, but each cube weighs almost nothing; the jar lasts longer than it appears. For pets with protein allergies, the cost is easier to swallow than novel-meat treats.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – two ingredients, human-grade fruit, probiotic retention, resealable metal canister.
Cons – strawberry dust settles on bottom, cubes shatter easily, fat content not listed for pancreatitis-prone dogs.
Bottom Line: A boutique topper that turns ordinary kibble into berry-flavored cereal. Rotate with protein treats to avoid too much sugar, and store in a dry cupboard to prevent clumping.
9. Milk-Bone Dipped Dog Biscuits Baked with Vanilla Yogurt, 12 oz., 4 Count
Overview: Milk-Bone Dipped Biscuits marry the classic crunch of Milk-Bone with a vanilla-yogurt flavored base coating. The 4-pack bundles four 12 oz bags—48 oz total—of small, fork-shaped biscuits suited for any breed.
What Makes It Stand Out: The half-dipped design gives dogs two textures in one bite: crunchy baked biscuit and a smooth yogurt-style frosting. Fans of the original Milk-Bone get a flavor upgrade without sacrificing the teeth-cleaning rigidity.
Value for Money: Cost per pound sits comfortably below boutique biscuits, and the multi-bag format keeps pantry trips rare. The yogurt coating does not contain live cultures, so you’re paying for taste, not probiotics.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – recognizable brand, resealable bags, no artificial colors or preservatives, made in Oklahoma.
Cons – coating can melt in hot cars, biscuits snap into sharp shards, not suitable for grain-sensitive dogs.
Bottom Line: A crowd-pleasing staple for neighborhood dog cookies or stocking stuffers. Store in a cool pantry and serve on a mat to catch yogurt smears.
10. Wellix Freeze-Dried Cat Treats for Dog&Cat – Triberry Cat&Dog Yogurt Treats with Chicken Flavor Fruits – Probiotics Digestive&Immune Health Cats&Dogs Food Toppers 4.23oz
Overview: Wellix tri-berry yogurt treats cram strawberries, blueberries, cranberries, and chicken-flavored yogurt into a freeze-dried nibble that works for both cats and dogs. The 4.23 oz tub offers probiotic fortification and antioxidant-rich fruit in equal measure.
What Makes It Stand Out: A 72 % yogurt base delivers real probiotics, while cranberries lend urinary-tract support often missing from canine snacks. The dual-species formula ends the cat-vs-dog treat segregation in multi-pet homes.
Value for Money: Mid-pack pricing per ounce, but you’re effectively buying two products in one—cat probiotic topper and dog training reward—softening the sticker shock.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – triple berry antioxidants, added probiotics, feline-safe, crumbles easily over meals.
Cons – chicken flavor is faint, fruit sugar adds calories, tub size runs small for large-breed training sessions.
Bottom Line: One tub on the counter replaces separate cat and dog treat jars. Pinch a few pieces for kitty, toss a handful to the pup, and enjoy the simplified shopping list.
Why Yogurt Deserves a Permanent Spot in Your Dog-Treat Rotation
Yogurt delivers three big canine wins: high-quality complete protein for lean muscle, calcium for strong bones, and live cultures that crowd out harmful gut bacteria. The fermentation process naturally reduces lactose, making it far easier to digest than plain milk. When you control the add-ins, you eliminate the refined sugars, carrageenan, and artificial flavors that sneak into commercial “yogurt drops.” Translation: you get functional food that pulls double duty as a tasty reward.
Understanding Canine Gut Health: How Probiotics in Yogurt Help
Roughly 70 percent of your dog’s immune cells live in the intestinal tract. Live yogurt cultures—primarily Lactobacillus acidophilus and Bifidobacterium animalis—compete with pathogenic bacteria for nutrients and gut-wall real estate, producing short-chain fatty acids that nourish the intestinal lining. The payoff is firmer stools, reduced gassiness, and fewer seasonal allergy flare-ups. Routine, modest servings keep microbial diversity high, which emerging research links to improved cognitive function in senior dogs.
Choosing the Best Base Yogurt: Ingredients, Fat Content & Label Red Flags
Scan the label for two words only: “live cultures.” Skip anything labeled “heat-treated after culturing,” a process that nukes the very bacteria you want. Plain, unsweetened, whole-milk yogurt offers the creamiest texture and healthy fats that slow digestion, preventing an insulin spike. Avoid xylitol, agave, honey, and fruit concentrates—dogs don’t need the extra sugar, and some substitutes are outright toxic. If your pup is overweight, 2 % Greek yogurt still delivers thick texture with fewer calories, but avoid fat-free versions that rely on fillers to mimic richness.
Frozen vs. Baked: Texture, Storage, and Serving Considerations
Frozen treats shine on hot days, last indefinitely in the freezer, and require zero cooking skills—just blend, pour, and freeze. They melt quickly, making them ideal outdoor snacks. Baked treats travel better in pockets and treat pouches, boast a shelf-stable week at room temperature, and let you incorporate flours for extra fiber. Decide which format fits your lifestyle (or make both), but never refreeze a melted pop; textural breakdown invites bacterial overgrowth.
Essential Equipment: Molds, Pans, and Storage Solutions You Already Own
Silicone ice-cube trays in fun shapes double as portion controllers—each cube equals about one tablespoon, a perfect mid-day bite for a 25-pound dog. Mini-muffin tins work for both frozen and baked versions; a quick spritz of coconut oil prevents sticking. If you bake often, invest in a reusable silicone mat; yogurt-based doughs are sticky, and parchment can wrinkle, leaving unbaked creases. Airtight freezer bags with the air pressed out prevent freezer burn for up to three months.
Flavor Building 101: Dog-Safe Fruits, Vegetables, and Superfood Add-Ins
Blueberries bring anthocyanins; spinach donates magnesium; turmeric adds anti-inflammatory punch. Always introduce one new ingredient at a time over three days to isolate potential allergens. Steer clear of grapes, raisins, onions, garlic, and the artificial sweetener xylitol. A safe rule: if you wouldn’t put it in a baby’s smoothie, don’t put it in your dog’s treat.
Texture Tricks: How to Prevent Icy, Rock-Hard Frozen Pops
Straight yogurt freezes into a chalky brick. Blend in 20–30 % ripe banana or a spoonful of plain applesauce; their natural pectins interrupt ice-crystal formation, yielding a creamy, scoopable texture even at zero degrees. A teaspoon of gelatin bloomed in two tablespoons of warm water also creates micro-air bubbles that keep the pop flexible enough to lick, not chip.
Baking Science: Achieving Crunch vs. Chewy Consistency
Yogurt introduces moisture and natural milk sugars that brown quickly. For crunch, bake low and slow—250 °F for 90 minutes—then shut the oven off and let the biscuits cool inside, dehydrating them further. Prefer a soft, cookie-like chew? Add an egg, raise the heat to 325 °F, and pull the pan when the centers spring back lightly, around 18 minutes.
Portion Control: Calculating Safe Daily Yogurt Intake by Dog Size
Veterinary nutritionists recommend that treats (all treats combined) stay below 10 % of daily caloric needs. One tablespoon of plain whole-milk yogurt adds roughly 9 kcal. A 50-pound, moderately active dog burns about 1,000 kcal per day, so three tablespoons split across several treats keeps you safely under the threshold. For tiny pups, think teaspoon, not tablespoon.
Allergy Watch: Lactose Intolerance vs. Dairy Protein Allergy
Lactose intolerance triggers loose stools or gas within 12 hours; a true dairy protein allergy sparks itchy skin or ear inflammation within days. Start with a lick-test: offer ½ teaspoon and monitor 24 hours. If all is calm, escalate gradually. Goat-milk yogurt has smaller fat globules and different casein structures, often tolerable for sensitive dogs.
Make-Ahead Meal-Prep: Batch Sizes, Freezing Timeline, and Thaw Safety
One standard 32-ounce tub yields roughly 60 one-tablespoon frozen cubes—enough for a medium dog for a month. Date the bag and rotate stock first-in, first-out. Thaw individual portions in the fridge, never on the counter, and serve within 24 hours. Baked biscuits can be vacuum-sealed in mason jars with an oxygen absorber for a shelf life of three weeks.
Ingredient Substitution Matrix: Swapping for Allergies, Weight Control, and Novel Proteins
Coconut yogurt offers a lactose-free, MCT-rich alternative, though it’s higher in fat—scale portions down by one-third. Pumpkin purée can replace banana for diabetic dogs; its lower glycemic load steadies blood sugar. If your dog needs novel proteins, mix in a tablespoon of hydrolyzed salmon powder instead of peanut butter to sidestep common allergens.
Holiday & Seasonal Twists: Festive Colors, Shapes, and Aromatics
Turn a standard paw print mold into a “pup-kin” spice delight by adding a pinch of cinnamon and turmeric for autumn color. At Christmas, shape dough into tiny trees and dust baked treats with dehydrated beet powder for a red “sprinkle” that’s antioxidant-rich yet stain-free. In summer, layer strawberry and spinach purées for a red-and-green bomb pop that photographs as well as it tastes.
Traveling With Yogurt Treats: Coolers, Dry Ice, and Shelf-Stable Alternatives
Frozen pops transport best in a vacuum-insulated lunch box with a slim reusable ice pack; they’ll stay rock-solid for four hours. For longer road trips, pre-freeze treats, then nestle them in a zip bag surrounded by dry ice pellets inside a vented cooler—never airtight, or CO₂ expansion will pop the lid. Baked biscuits are simpler: vacuum-sealed strips tucked into a glove box survive a 12-hour drive without crumbling.
Common Mistakes That Turn Healthy Treats Into Tummy Aches
Overdoing peanut butter (high fat), skipping the intro phase for new fruits, or using yogurt sweetened with “evaporated cane juice” are the top three slip-ups. Another rookie error: refreezing partially thawed pops multiple times—each cycle degrades texture and invites bacteria. Finally, ignoring calorie math can quietly pack on pounds; measure, don’t eyeball.
Troubleshooting Guide: Runny Mixtures, Cracked Biscuits, and Freezer Burn Fixes
If your frozen mixture separates, you blended too fast; pulse on low or hand-stir to keep emulsification. Cracked baked biscuits mean the oven temp spiked—use an oven thermometer to verify accuracy. Freezer burn appears as icy fuzz; trim the affected layer or brush lightly with warm water and refreeze for 10 minutes to rehydrate the surface.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can puppies eat yogurt treats, or is it just for adult dogs?
Yes, puppies over 12 weeks can enjoy small amounts; start with ½ teaspoon and ensure the treat size fits their tiny jaws to prevent choking.
2. Is Greek yogurt better than regular yogurt for dogs?
Greek yogurt is higher in protein and lower in lactose, making it an excellent choice unless your vet has prescribed a restricted-protein diet.
3. How long do homemade yogurt dog treats last in the freezer?
Up to three months when stored in an airtight bag with excess air removed, though peak flavor and texture occur within the first month.
4. My dog is on a low-fat diet; can I still make yogurt treats?
Absolutely—use non-fat plain yogurt and complement with low-calorie add-ins like cucumber purée to maintain volume without fat.
5. What’s the quickest way to defrost a single frozen pop without microwaving?
Place the pop in a zip bag and submerge it in room-temperature water for five minutes; it will soften just enough to lick.
6. Are there any signs that my dog is allergic to yogurt?
Watch for itching, hives, ear infections, or loose stools within 24–48 hours of introduction; discontinue if any appear and consult your vet.
7. Can I add collagen or bone broth powder to the recipes?
Yes, both dissolve readily in yogurt and provide joint-supporting amino acids; account for the extra protein in daily calorie totals.
8. Do I need to cook fruit before adding it to baked yogurt treats?
No, but steaming apples or berries for two minutes breaks down cell walls, releasing antioxidants and intensifying natural sweetness.
9. How do I transport frozen treats to the dog park on a hot day?
Pre-freeze in silicone tubes, pop them into an insulated wine chiller with a frozen gel sleeve, and serve within two hours for optimal texture.
10. Can yogurt treats replace a meal?
No—they lack complete vitamin-mineral balance. Keep them under 10 % of daily calories and use as rewards or meal toppers only.
