For many dog owners, the weekly or monthly excitement of a BarkBox delivery has become a cherished ritual. The colorful packaging, the element of surprise, and most importantly the delightful toys and treats inside bring joy not just to our canine companions but to us as well. Among the most popular items in these subscription boxes are the famous BarkBox “dumplings” and themed toys that captivate dogs’ attention while satisfying their natural instincts to chew, fetch, and destroy.
As we look ahead to 2025, the landscape of dog subscription boxes continues to evolve, with greater emphasis on sustainability, engagement, and customization. The themed toys and unique dumpling designs have become increasingly sophisticated, incorporating puzzle elements, different textures, and innovative materials that keep dogs engaged for longer periods. Understanding what makes these toys special and how to select the best options can significantly enhance your dog’s playtime experience while ensuring safety and value for money.
Top 10 Barkbox Dumplings
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Barkbox Dog Toy 2 in 1 Interactive, Plush Exterior Material & Squeaker, Tearable Dog Toy with Squeaky Ball Inside, Ideal for Toy Destroyers – Andi’s Dumpling, Small
Overview: The Barkbox Andi’s Dumpling interactive dog toy combines a plush exterior with a hidden squeaky ball, creating a 2-in-1 play experience that keeps dogs engaged. Priced at $11.99, this small-sized toy features a multi-part design that can be torn apart to reveal another toy inside, extending playtime.
What Makes It Stand Out: The unique tear-and-reveal concept transforms standard playtime into an interactive discovery experience. Textured materials provide sensory stimulation, while the double-layered construction offers durability that surpasses many single-toy options in its price range.
Value for Money: At $11.99, this toy offers excellent value as it essentially provides two toys in one. The pricing aligns well with Barkbox’s established quality standards and the play-testing by over 50 million dogs suggests good longevity for the price point.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the interactive design that appeals to dogs’ natural curiosity, the dual quality/entertainment aspect, and the sensory engagement from varied textures. Weaknesses may include that very determined chewers might still destroy it relatively quickly, and the smaller size limits its use to small dogs only.
Bottom Line: The Andi’s Dumpling toy offers great entertainment value at an accessible price point, especially for smaller dogs with moderate chewing tendencies. The dual-toy concept makes it stand out in the pet toy market, providing multiple play experiences in a single purchase that most owners will find worth the investment.
2. Barkbox Dog Toys – Barker’s Dozen Donuts Plush 4 in 1 Multi Part Interactive Dog Toy for Dogs & Puppies – Small
Overview: Barker’s Dozen Donuts from Barkbox presents a whimsical 4-in-1 interactive dog toy package priced at $12.99. This collection features a donut-shaped design with multiple components including squeakers and a crinkly exterior, making it perfect for multifaceted play experiences.
What Makes It Stand Out: The donut-themed box contains four separate toys that can be used individually together, offering exceptional versatility. The triple squeaker design combined with crinkle material creates an extra-engaging sensory experience that appeals to dogs with various play preferences.
Value for Money: At $12.99 for a 4-in-1 set, this represents excellent value at approximately $3.25 per toy, significantly better than purchasing individual toys separately. The quality construction using non-toxic materials further enhances the perceived value.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the variety of play options, the high-quality crinkle material that withstands repeated crunching, and the safe construction. Weaknesses are that multiple small pieces may create potential choking hazards if damaged, and some dogs might lose interest after discovering all components.
Bottom Line: The Barker’s Dozen Donuts set delivers exceptional entertainment variety for the price, especially for curious and energetic small to medium dogs. The combination of squeaky and crinkly elements makes it particularly engaging, though owners should supervise play, especially with more destructive chewers.
3. Barkbox 2 in 1 Interactive Plush Dog Toy – Rip and Reveal Toy for Dogs and Puppies – Stimulating Squeaky Pet Toys | Prickly Pete (Small)
Overview: The Barkbox Prickly Pete 2-in-1 interactive toy ($12.99) features a unique rip-and-reveal design where dogs can tear through the outer layer to discover a spiky ball squeaker inside. The crinkle material combined with the textured exterior provides multi-sensory stimulation for dogs.
What Makes It Stand Out: The spiky ball design inside adds an unexpected tactile element that differentiates this toy from standard squeaky toys. The New York City-inspired design aesthetic combines durability with whimsical charm, appealing equally to dogs and their owners.
Value for Money: At $12.99, this single toy with double the entertainment value provides solid pricing in Barkbox’s range. The attention to material quality and thoughtful design justifies the cost, especially for pet owners seeking engaging toys that last longer than basic alternatives.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the engaging multi-layer experience, the durable construction designed for thorough play-testing, and the combination of squeaky and crinkle elements. Weaknesses are that the spiky interior might pose minimal discomfort to some dogs during play, and the toy is only available in small size.
Bottom Line: Prickly Pete delivers on its promise of extended play engagement through its innovative design. The combination of textures, sounds, and interactive discovery makes it worth the investment for small dogs with moderate chewing habits, though it may not satisfy the most aggressive chewers.
4. Barkbox Squeaky Dog Toys – Plush and Squeak Chew Toys | Puppy and Pet Toys for Small to Medium Dogs | Chow Chow Mein (Medium)
Overview: The Chow Chow Mein squeaky dog toy from Barkbox ($14.49) features a Chinese take-out box design with plush “noodles” and “chopsticks.” This medium-sized toy combines whimsical design with functional play elements for small to medium dogs.
What Makes It Stand Out: The themed design transforms everyday play into a culinary adventure, with multiple components (box, noodles, chopsticks) that can be played with individually or together. The attention to detail in the design provides an element of owner appreciation beyond just being a dog toy.
Value for Money: At $14.49, this single toy sits slightly higher than Barkbox’s 2-in-1 options, but the thematic complexity and multi-component structure offer a different type of value. The medium size also extends its usability across more breeds than many single-purpose toys.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the multi-component design that supports various play styles, the visual appeal for owners, and the thorough testing for durability. Weaknesses are that individual components might separate more easily than expected with aggressive play, and the themed design might appeal less to serious chewers.
Bottom Line: The Chow Chow Mein toy delivers on both entertainment value and aesthetic appeal, making it an excellent choice for owners who enjoy seeing their dogs play with thoughtfully designed toys. While pricier than some alternatives, the quality and engagement potential make it worthwhile for small to medium dogs with diverse play preferences.
5. Barkbox Dog Toy 2 in 1 Interactive, Plush Exterior with Squeaker & Crinkle Material, Tearable Dog Toy with Squeaky Spikey Ball Inside, Ideal for Toy Destroyers – Woofles Chips, Small
Overview: The Woofles Chips interactive dog toy ($15.49) features three plush potato chips contained within a crinkly bag with velcro closure. This 2-in-1 design combines treat-hiding potential with multiple play elements for enhanced engagement.
What Makes It Stand Out: The velcro closure design allows owners to hide treats inside, creating an interactive puzzle element that extends playtime beyond simple chewing or squeaking. The chip theme provides a humorous and recognizable concept that connects to everyday objects in an unexpected way.
Value for Money: At $15.49, this is one of the higher-priced Barkbox options, but the combination of multiple play elements and treat-hiding potential increases value. The larger size also extends usability to a broader range of dogs compared to the smallest options in their lineup.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the treat-hiding capability for mental stimulation, the durable construction designed for heavy chewers, and the engaging crinkle material. Weaknesses are that the velcro closure may eventually wear down with repeated use, and the higher price point might deter budget-conscious buyers.
Bottom Line: The Woofles Chips toy delivers through its combination of physical and mental stimulation, appealing particularly to dogs that enjoy both chewing and puzzle-solving. Though slightly pricier, the versatility and engagement potential make it worth the investment for dog owners seeking more sophisticated play options.
6. Barkbox Signore Pizza Face Dog Toy | Fluff-Free Crinkle Pizza Toy with T-Shirt Rope | Durable Dog Toys Dogs & Puppy Essentials
Overview: The Barkbox Signore Pizza Face Dog Toy is a fluff-free plush toy designed in the shape of a pizza face with a t-shirt rope crust. This innovative toy combines the fun of a crinkle filling with the durability of rope material, offering a multi-sensory experience for dogs without the typical mess of stuffed toys.
What Makes It Stand Out: The pizza-shaped design with its fluff-free construction makes this toy unique, addressing the common issue of stuffing cleanup after play. The combination of crinkle material for sound stimulation and the rope crust for dental health and tug-of-war games provides multiple ways for dogs to engage.
Value for Money: At $10.99, this toy offers good value. The dual-material design (plush and rope) creates durability that exceeds single-material toys at similar price points. The fact that it’s designed for all dog sizes extends its utility in multi-pet households.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the no-mess design, dual-texture stimulation, washable materials, and versatility for different play styles. Weakesnes may include eventual fraying of the rope crust over time with heavy use and crinkle material potentially losing its effectiveness after extended chewing by power chewers.
Bottom Line: The Signore Pizza Face Dog Toy is an excellent choice for owners frustrated with stuffing cleanup but unwilling to sacrifice fun. Its creative design and dual functionality provide hours of entertainment while addressing common pain points of dog toys.
7. Barkbox Cherry Blasto Pop Dog Toy | Durable Nylon Popsicle Chew Toy for Aggressive Chewers | Dog Toys for Small Dogs, Puppy Teething Toys & Summer Fun
Overview: The Barkbox Cherry Blasto Pop Dog Toy is a durable, solid nylon popsicle toy designed specifically for aggressive chewers. Infused with a tempting cherry scent and featuring treat-holding grooves, this toy combines durability with sensory appeal to keep determined chewers engaged.
What Makes It Stand Out: Its solid nylon construction makes it exceptionally durable, outlasting many chew toys on the market. The cherry scent adds an extra dimension of appeal, while the grooves allow for treat placement that turns chewing into a rewarding activity and extends playtime.
Value for Money: At $14.49, this toy is competitively priced for the durable construction quality. The treat-holding grooves effectively add value by allowing owners to use food to prolong interest, potentially reducing the need for additional treat-dispensing toys.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Key strengths include exceptional durability for aggressive chewers, scent appeal, dental benefits from textured surface, and treat-holding design. Weaknesses might include hardness that could deter some dogs, potential to damage floors if thrown, and limited squeaker-free play options compared to plush toys.
Bottom Line: The Cherry Blasto Pop is an excellent investment for owners of power chewers who frequently destroy less durable toys. Its combination of toughness, scent attraction, and treat functionality makes it a valuable addition to any chew toy collection, justifying its price point for pet owners tired of constantly replacing toys.
8. Barkbox Clown Fishing Around Plush Toy for Small Dogs – 2-Part Squeaky Toy with Treat-Hiding Fun – Perfect for Interactive Play and Mental Stimulation
Overview: The Barkbox Clown Fishing Around Plush Toy is a two-part interactive toy designed specifically for small dogs, featuring a clownfish and anemone set with treat-hiding capabilities and dual squeakers. This toy combines physical play with mental stimulation to engage dogs in multiple ways.
What Makes It Stand Out: The unique two-in-one design allows for both interactive play between dogs and solo fun. The treat-hiding anemone component adds a puzzle element that challenges dogs mentally while the fish provides tactile play. This combination of physical and cognitive engagement sets it apart from standard plush toys.
Value for Money: Priced at $13.99, this toy offers good value due to its dual functionality and durable construction for its class. The treat-hiding feature effectively extends the toy’s lifespan by continuously renewing a dog’s interest as they try to access hidden rewards.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include the dual toy design, treat-hiding capability, engaging squeakers and crinkle material, and mental stimulation benefits. Weaknesses may include limited durability for aggressive chewers, potential squeaker failure with heavy use, and the small size might not be suitable for larger dogs.
Bottom Line: The Clown Fishing Around toy is an excellent choice for small dog owners seeking to provide both physical and mental stimulation. Its innovative design and interactive elements make playtime more engaging and rewarding, though it’s best suited for gentler play rather than aggressive chewing.
9. Barkbox Sheila Sugar Glidah Plush Toy for X-Small Dogs – 2-in-1 Squeaky & Crazy Crinkle Fun – Perfect for Fetch, Tug, and Interactive Playtime
Overview: The Barkbox Sheila Sugar Glidah Plush Toy is a 2-in-1 interactive toy designed specifically for x-small dogs, featuring a hidden surprise toy, dual squeakers, and crinkle material for maximum engagement. This toy combines multiple textures and sounds to keep small dogs entertained.
What Makes It Stand Out: The unique hidden surprise toy feature adds an element of discovery that maintains a dog’s interest long after initial play. Combined with double squeakers and crinkle material, this creates a multi-sensory experience that addresses different aspects of canine play preferences in a single toy.
Value for Money: At $12.99, this toy offers good value for its target market of x-small dogs. The multi-functional design reduces the need for purchasing separate toys for different play styles, making it a cost-effective solution for small dog owners.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Key strengths include the hidden toy feature for extended engagement, double squeakers, crinkle material, and appropriate size for small breeds. Weaknesses include limited durability for aggressive chewers and potential safety concerns if dogs manage to access the hidden toy and ingest parts.
Bottom Line: The Sheila Sugar Glidah is well-designed for x-small dogs, offering multiple forms of stimulation in one convenient package. Its innovative features particularly appeal to curious small dogs, though owners should monitor playtime with chewers who might attempt to destroy its inner components.
10. Barkbox Super Chewer Tough Dog Chew Toys for Aggressive Chewers, Dental Stimulating (Turkey – Small)
Overview: The Barkbox Super Chewer Tough Dog Chew Toy is a durable, food-scented toy designed specifically for aggressive chewers, featuring a natural rubber exterior with a tough nylon core. This turkey-scented toy combines durability with dental stimulation to provide a long-lasting chewing experience.
What Makes It Stand Out: The unique combination of natural rubber and nylon core creates a durable yet flexible toy that stands up to prolonged chewing by even the most determined chewers. Its drumstick design offers an easy grip shape while the turkey scent adds an irresistible olfactory element.
Value for Money: At $16.49, this toy represents a higher price point but justifies the cost through exceptional durability and specialized design for aggressive chewers. By lasting significantly longer than conventional chew toys, it offers better long-term value despite the higher initial investment.
Strengths and Weaknesses: Strengths include exceptional durability specifically designed for power chewers, dental stimulating texture, safe materials (no stuffing or rope), and appealing scent. Weaknesses include higher cost, potential for being too hard for some dogs’ teeth, and limited versatility compared to multi-purpose toys.
Bottom Line: The Super Chewer Tough Dog Chew Toy is an excellent investment for owners of aggressive chewers who frequently destroy conventional toys. Its specialized construction and durability make it worth the premium price, providing a safe and long-lasting outlet for chewing instincts.
Understanding the World of BarkBox Dumplings and Themed Toys
What Are BarkBox Dumplings?
BarkBox dumplings represent a unique category of dog toys designed with a distinctive pillow-like or pouch-like appearance. These toys typically feature reinforced stitching, multiple textures, and often include crinkle materials or squeakers to capture canine interest. The dumpling design offers an appealing shape that’s easy for dogs to grab, carry, and mouth while providing durability through double-layered construction and strategic seam reinforcement.
The Evolution of Dog Subscription Toys
Subscription-based dog toys have transformed significantly over the past decade, moving beyond simple chew items to sophisticated play systems. Modern themed toys often incorporate elements of cognitive engagement, alternating textures, and sometimes even treat-dispensing capabilities. The dumpling format has proven particularly successful due to its versatility—it can be adapted to various themes, sizes, and difficulty levels while maintaining structural integrity.
Why Dogs Love Themed Playthings
Dogs are naturally drawn to novelty and variety in their environment, and themed toys tap into this preference by offering familiar play structures in fresh, exciting designs. The psychological aspect of new stimuli prevents boredom and associated behavioral issues. Additionally, themed toys often incorporate elements that appeal to specific canine instincts, from the crinkly textures that mimic prey to the durable exteriors that withstand vigorous chewing, making them both mentally and physically satisfying.
Evaluating Quality and Safety Features
Material Considerations for Dog Toys
When evaluating any dog toy, regardless of its theme or design, the materials used in its construction are paramount to both safety and durability. Quality dog toys should use non-toxic, pet-safe materials that can withstand significant chewing without breaking into harmful pieces. Look for FDA-approved materials, BPA-free components, and specifically formulated compounds that resist degradation from dog saliva and chewing motions.
Size Appropriateness for Your Dog
One of the most critical factors in selecting appropriate toys is matching them to your dog’s size, weight, and chewing strength. Toys that are too small pose choking hazards for large breeds, while toys that are too large may be cumbersome for small dogs to play with effectively. Consider not just your dog’s current size but also their growth potential if they’re still a puppy, as well as their individual chewing style—whether they’re gentle mouthers, dedicated chewers, or aggressive “destroyers” of toys.
Durable Construction Techniques
Examination of construction techniques provides insight into a toy’s longevity and safety profile. Look for reinforced stitching, particularly at stress points where seams come together. Double-layered or triple-layered fabric construction significantly extends the life of plush-style toys. For rubber or composite toys, examine the thickness of the material and the absence of weak points that might fracture under pressure. Quality toys also feature securely embedded components like squeakers that cannot be easily chewed out or swallowed.
Non-Toxic and Safe Materials
Beyond general material safety, specific certifications and standards indicate a manufacturer’s commitment to pet health. ISO-certified production facilities, adherence to ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) standards for pet products, and clear labeling of materials all contribute to a safer play experience. Avoid toys with chemical odors, visible discolorations, or irregularities that might indicate manufacturing defects or material degradation.
Selecting the Right Themed Toys for Your Dog
Matching Toys to Your Dog’s Play Style
Dogs exhibit distinct play preferences that should inform toy selection. Some are dedicated fetchers who prefer toys that can be thrown and retrieved, while others are passionate chewers who need durable toys designed to withstand vigorous chewing. Some dogs enjoy puzzle toys that challenge their problem-solving abilities, while others prefer simple comfort objects they can carry around. Observing which types of toys your dog naturally gravitates toward helps ensure that themed toys will actually be used and enjoyed.
Considering Your Dog’s Breed Characteristics
Different breeds have developed distinct traits through generations of selective breeding that influence their play preferences and needs. Retrievers often enjoy fetching and water-based play, terriers typically exhibit strong hunting and “kill” behaviors with small toys, and herding breeds may prefer toys that can be chased and herded. Understanding these breed tendencies can help you select themed toys that align with your dog’s instincts, making playtime more satisfying and appropriate.
Introducing Variety in Your Dog’s Toy Collection
Dogs, like humans, benefit from variety in their play environment. A diverse collection of themed toys that engage different senses and stimulate various play behaviors prevents boredom and maintains interest over time. Consider incorporating toys that stimulate different play modalities—auditory (squeakers, crinkles), tactile (various textures), cognitive (puzzle elements), and physical (different shapes for various mouth grips and chewing actions)—into your dog’s toy rotation.
Seasonal and Holiday-Themed Considerations
Seasonal themed toys can add extra excitement to your dog’s play routine during special times of year. Holiday-themed options often incorporate appropriate seasonal elements while maintaining safety and durability standards. When selecting these themed items, ensure they don’t contain small, detachable parts that could pose choking hazards, and verify that any seasonal additions (like bells, ribbons, or themed graphics) are securely attached and made from non-toxic materials.
Maximizing Engagement and Enrichment
Interactive Elements to Look For
The most engaging dog toys incorporate interactive elements that respond to a dog’s actions, creating a dynamic play experience rather than a static object. Squeakers that emit different tones or volumes, crinkle materials that produce pleasing sounds, and textures that change sensation as a dog mouths the toy all increase engagement. These interactive elements tap into a dog’s natural prey drive and curiosity, encouraging active play rather than passive chewing.
Puzzle Features and Mental Stimulation
Modern themed toys often incorporate puzzle elements that challenge a dog mentally as well as physically. Treat-dispensing features, hidden compartments, or mechanisms that require specific actions to access rewards provide mental enrichment that tires dogs out faster than physical exercise alone. These puzzle elements should be appropriate for your dog’s problem-solving abilities—challenging enough to be interesting but not so difficult as to cause frustration and abandonment of the toy.
Play Versatility for Long-Term Interest
The most valuable toys offer multiple play modes within a single design, extending their usefulness and maintaining a dog’s interest over time. Versatile designs might function as both chew toys and fetch toys, incorporate treat-dispensing capabilities that can be modified for difficulty levels, or feature removable components that can be played with independently or reassembled. This versatility provides better value for money while keeping your dog engaged with a familiar toy in fresh ways.
Durability Factors for Extended Play
Beyond initial durability, consider how a toy performs during extended play sessions. High-quality materials resist the breakdown that occurs with repeated moisture exposure from saliva, preventing the growth of harmful bacteria. Reinforced stress points maintain integrity during vigorous play sessions, and toys that retain their shape after being mouthed or chewed continue to provide appropriate tactile feedback. These factors collectively contribute to a toy’s ability to remain engaging and safe throughout its usable lifespan.
Caring for Your Dog’s Themed Toys
Cleaning and Maintenance Guidelines
Regular cleaning ensures your dog’s themed toys remain hygienic and safe for extended use. Most fabric-based toys can be hand-washed with pet-safe detergents or even machine-washed on gentle cycles if they lack electronic components like squeakers. Rubber and composite toys typically benefit from regular scrubbing with warm, soapy water or periodic runs through the dishwasher (if labeled dishwasher-safe). Establishing a cleaning routine based on your dog’s usage patterns and saliva levels helps prevent the buildup of bacteria that could lead to health issues.
Identifying When to Retire a Toy
Recognizing when a toy has reached the end of its safe lifespan is crucial to prevent potential health hazards. Look for signs of significant wear such as loose threads that could be ingested, cracks or fractures in hard materials, thinning fabric that could be punctured, or exposed internal components like squeakers or stuffing. These indicators signal that a toy should be retired immediately and replaced, as continued use could result in choking hazards or intestinal blockages if pieces are swallowed.
Storage Solutions for Toy Collections
Proper toy storage helps maintain their condition and safety between uses. Dedicated toy bins or baskets keep toys contained while allowing for easy rotation. For themed collections, consider organizing by type, size, or theme to streamline playtime selection. Storage should be in a location that’s accessible to your dog but away from direct sunlight, moisture, and extreme temperatures that could degrade materials. Avoid storing toys in tight spaces that could deform rubber components or crush soft toys.
Rotating Toys to Maintain Interest
Regular toy rotation is a proven strategy to maintain your dog’s interest in their playthings. By keeping only a subset of available toys out at any given time and rotating them weekly or bi-weekly, you reintroduce familiar toys as novel experiences. This practice prevents boredom while allowing regular inspection and cleaning of toys not currently in use. Keep a record of which toys are rotated out and when, ensuring each toy receives equal attention and that none becomes overlooked or damaged from long-term storage.
Frequently Asked Questions
- How often should I rotate my dog’s toys?
- Are themed toys safer than regular dog toys?
- Can I leave my dog unsupervised with these toys?
- What should I do if my dog swallows a piece of a toy?
- How can I tell if a toy is too small for my dog?
- Are there any materials I should avoid in dog toys?
- Why do dogs love squeaky toys so much?
- How many toys should my dog have access to at once?
- Can these themed toys help with behavioral issues?
- Are long-lasting toys worth the higher cost?