Ol’ Roy has been a household name in budget-friendly dog treats for decades, but in 2025 the conversation has shifted from “cheap” to “best-value”—a subtle change that signals pet parents want more tail-wags per dollar and more confidence about safety. Whether you shop the sprawling Ol’ Roy wall at Walmart or browse the newly-expanded online aisle, you’ve probably wondered which formulations actually deliver muscle-building protein, joint-supporting glucosamine, or simply a guilt-free cookie that won’t spike your pup’s blood sugar. Below, we peel back the label jargon, digest the latest FDA and AAFCO guidance, and walk you through the lens you should use before any bag or box lands in your cart.
Figuring out the “best-value” pick is a moving target: ingredient costs fluctuate, manufacturing lots shift, and your own dog’s life stage or medical condition evolves month to month. Rather than hand you a static top-10 list that could be outdated by summer, this guide equips you with an evergreen framework—so every time Ol’ Roy tweaks a recipe, changes a supplier, or drops a new functional line, you’ll know exactly how to judge safety, nutrition, and true bang-for-buck on the spot.
Top 10 Ol Roy Dog Treats Recall 2020
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Ol’ Roy Beefhide Chicken Coated Munchy Sticks 40 Count Dog Treats, 16.9 Ounce Bag
Overview: Ol’ Roy Beefhide Chicken Coated Munchy Sticks deliver 40 individually wrapped chews in a resealable 16.9-oz bag. Marketed for every life stage and breed, they put chicken breast first on a short ingredient list and include weight-based feeding guidelines on the back.
What Makes It Stand Out: The thin “munchy” profile is easy for small mouths yet still gives medium dogs a satisfying few minutes of gnawing. The chicken coating adds aroma that entices even picky seniors without adding messy crumbs to your carpet.
Value for Money: At roughly $0.61 per stick, the bag undercuts premium rolled-chews by half while lasting the average beagle household an entire month.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Strengths – resealable pouch keeps sticks pliable, uniform size limits choking risk, no artificial colors.
Weaknesses – beefhide base can swell if gulped, coating may stain light fur, odor is strong for human noses.
Bottom Line: A wallet-friendly everyday chew for supervised snack time; not for vigorous power-chewers but ideal for rewarding good behavior without breaking the bank.
2. Munchy Bone Dog Treats, Variety Pack, 21 Count, 60 oz | Long-Lasting Chews for All Dog Sizes | Assorted Flavors: Chicken, Liver, Peanut Butter
Overview: Munchy Bone’s 21-count variety tub (60 oz total) promises durable chews in chicken, liver, and peanut butter flavors, each fortified with vitamins to complement any size dog’s diet.
What Makes It Stand Out: The three-flavor rotation keeps heavy chewers from boredom, while the dense baked texture scrapes plaque during extended chew sessions—owners report 20-30 minutes of quiet time even from 70-lb Labrador jaws.
Value for Money: Priced at $1.86 per chew, they cost more than rawhide but outlast most biscuits 3:1, driving the hourly entertainment cost below a dollar.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Strengths – no rawhide means gentler digestion, resealable tub stores neatly, visible vitamin specks reassure nutrition claims.
Weaknesses – calories add up fast for small dogs, strongest scent (liver) can linger on hands, some batches arrive cracked.
Bottom Line: If your priority is long-lasting chew time with dental benefits and you don’t mind paying upfront, this variety pack earns its keep and your dog’s devotion.
3. Ol’ Roy Rawhide Free Chicken Flavor Twist Sticks Dog Treats, 16 Ounces
Overview: Ol’ Roy Rawhide-Free Chicken Twist Sticks offer 50 skinny spirals in a 16-oz bag, using real chicken minus rawhide or artificial flavors to create a light, digestible reward.
What Makes It Stand Out: The twist shape slows intake, letting tiny terriers and giant mastiffs alike enjoy the same SKU—no size-specific SKUs to juggle.
Value for Money: 38¢ per stick is among the lowest rawhide-alternative prices on the shelf; one bag satisfies a 30-lb dog for six weeks of daily rewards.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Strengths – breaks down quickly in stomachs sensitive to traditional hides, mild chicken smell won’t stink up pockets, individually thin sticks make training portions easy.
Weaknesses – aggressive chewers finish in under two minutes, twists can fragment sharp if dried out, packaging isn’t resealable.
Bottom Line: A solid everyday “good-dog” token for households prioritizing digestibility; pair with a freezer-grade zip bag to maintain freshness.
4. Ol’s~Roys Rawhide Free Twist Sticks with Chicken Dog Treats, 16 Oz ~ (50 Count) ~ 1 Pack
Overview: Labeled nearly identically to Product 3, this 16-oz, 50-count twist-stick bag nevertheless swaps in peanut butter plus chicken for a dual-flavor punch while still banning rawhide.
What Makes It Stand Out: Peanut butter aroma produces Pavlov-level drool, yet stick fat stays under 4%, making it one of the leanest flavored chews in the rawhide-free niche.
Value for Money: At $1.03 per ounce it’s the cheapest rawhide-alternative Ol’ Roy line, underbidding Product 3 by 13%.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Strengths – re-closable zipper keeps twists supple, easy on sensitive tummies, texture lightly flosses molars.
Weaknesses – peanut scent may trigger allergies in some households, lighter density means power-chewers conquer in 60 seconds, inconsistent twist tightness.
Bottom Line: Best choice for trainers needing high-value, low-cost motivators; just keep an eye on dogs that inhale rather than chew.
5. Ol’~Roy Jerky Stick Dog Treats with Real Beef Chews ~ 25 Oz Box ~ (2 Pack)
Overview: The twin 25-oz boxes of Ol’ Roy Jerky Sticks give you 50 oz of real beef strips—think Slim-Jim style but formulated for canine nutrition—totaling 2 lbs of chewy protein.
What Makes It Stand Out: True jerky texture satisfies scavenging instincts better than soft moist treats, while natural chewing friction helps scale tartar; owners liken it to “dental floss that tastes like steak.”
Value for Money: $0.72 per oz undercuts most grocery-aisle jerkies by 40%, and the shelf-stable cardboard boxes mean zero plastic waste.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Strengths – beef is first ingredient, easy to tear into smaller obedience rewards, no overpowering smoke flavor.
Weaknesses – salt content demands limited quantities for seniors, strips can harden if box left open, not suitable for dogs with beef allergies.
Bottom Line: A bargain bulk jerky that doubles as entertainment and teeth cleaner; portion wisely and you’ll have months of tail wags for under eighteen bucks.
6. Ol’ Roy Bark’n Bac’n Dog Treats, (Bark’n Bac’n, 50-Ounce)
Overview: Ol’ Roy Bark’n Bac’n Dog Treats deliver 50 ounces of smoky, bacon-flavored biscuits that promise to turn any good dog into an instant beggar. The resealable pouch keeps the crunchy strips fresh for daily rewarding, training or plain spoiling.
What Makes It Stand Out: Few treats offer this sheer volume at grocery-store convenience; the uniform strips break cleanly for portion control, and the scent is strong enough to grab every nose in the park without being greasy to touch.
Value for Money: At about 36¢ per ounce you’ll struggle to find a cheaper calorie of canine joy; a single bag can refill the cookie jar for a multi-dog household for well over a month, making it one of the lowest-cost-per-treat options on the market.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – wallet-friendly bulk, long shelf life, dogs universally love the smoky aroma, easy to snap into training-sized bits.
Cons – contains artificial colors, salt and bacon “flavor” rather than real meat; not ideal for sodium-sensitive or allergy-prone pups; crumbs collect at the bottom of the bag.
Bottom Line: If you need an inexpensive, high-volume biscuit that keeps tails wagging, Bark’n Bac’n earns a spot in the pantry. Just don’t mistake it for health food—feed mindfully and keep water nearby.
7. Ol’ Roy 50-Ounce Bark’n Bac’n Treats, Twin Pack, Two 25oz. Stay Fresh Pouches
Overview: This twin-pack gives you two 25-ounce stay-fresh pouches of Ol’ Roy’s classic Bark’n Bac’n biscuits—50 ounces total—marketed as a convenience bundle for multi-dog homes or anyone who hates running out of snacks.
What Makes It Stand Out: Separate pouches mean you open only half at a time, preserving crunch and aroma without an industrial-sized lid; the price difference versus the single 50-oz bag is usually pennies, so you’re essentially getting free built-in freshness insurance.
Value for Money: At roughly 40¢ per ounce (a hair above the single sack) the up-charge is minimal for the added portability—perfect for keeping one pouch in the kitchen and another in the car or at a relative’s house.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – resealable twin packs prevent staleness, same crowd-pleasing bacon scent, easy to share with friends or donate to shelters, breakable strips suit training.
Cons – ingredient list is identical to the single bag (fillers, salt, artificial smoke); packaging still produces a fair bit of crumb dust; environmental impact of two mylar bags versus one.
Bottom Line: Choose the twin pack if convenience beats absolute lowest cost. Otherwise, save the plastic and grab the single pouch—you’re getting the same biscuit either way.
8. Ol’ Roy Rawhide Free Peanut Butter Flavor Twist Sticks Dog Treats, 9.7oz
Overview: Ol’ Roy Rawhide-Free Peanut Butter Twist Sticks offer a 9.7-oz resealable bag holding 50 peanut-butter-and-chino chews designed for owners who want rawhide’s occupancy time without the digestion drama.
What Makes It Stand Out: The twists genuinely contain zero rawhide; instead a mix of chicken and peanut butter is extruded into a pliable chew that flexes rather than splinters, helping scrub plaque while keeping stomachs calm.
Value for Money: Around $1.85 per ounce these cost more than economy biscuits, yet undercut premium rawhide alternatives by half; given 50 sticks, each twist runs about 36¢—reasonable for a moderate-duration chew.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – highly digestible, no sharp chunks, works for tiny jaws or power chewers, pleasant peanut aroma rather than slaughter-house stench, low fat.
Cons – disappears in minutes with heavy chewers, sticks can fuse in humid weather, added chicken means not vegetarian despite PB marketing, calorie count adds up fast if you hand out multiples.
Bottom Line: A solid mid-priced rawhide substitute that cleans teeth and satisfies cravings without late-night panic vet calls. Stock up for moderate chewers; giant gnashers may still need something more durable.
9. Ol~Roy Bark’n Bac’n Lean Dog Treats with Real Bacon Chews ~ 25 Oz Pouch ~ (1 Pack)
Overview: Bark’n Bac’n Lean trims a few calories from the original by featuring real meat as ingredient #1, then packing 25 ounces of softer, bacon-laden strips into a single stay-fresh pouch.
What Makes It Stand Out: Unlike the classic version, “Lean” isn’t just a marketing buzzword—fat drops from 9% to 5% and salt is lowered, giving trainers a treat they can dole out generously without blowing daily calorie budgets.
Value for Money: At roughly 25¢ per ounce this is the cheapest “real meat first” treat on most shelves; you’re basically paying mid-tier kibble prices for something your dog thinks is jerky.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – first ingredient is meat, tender texture suits senior dogs or puppies, lower fat reduces pancreatitis worry, resealable pouch, still smells irresistible.
Cons – smaller 25-oz bag empties fast in multi-dog homes, softer feel means less dental benefit, some batches arrive overly crumbly in shipping.
Bottom Line: For owners wanting guilt-free rewarding or anyone with a tooth-challenged pooch, Bark’n Bac’n Lean hits the sweet spot between affordability and upgraded nutrition. Buy two—you’ll go through them faster than you expect.
10. Ol’ Roy Rawhide 2.5″ Roll with Chicken Dog Treats 36 Count Per Bag
Overview: Ol’ Roy Rawhide 2.5″ Rolls marry a thin sheet of rawhide around a chicken-flavored stuffing, delivering 36 chews per bag aimed at satisfying moderate gnawers while keeping grocery spending sane.
What Makes It Stand Out: The basted chicken layer turns boring rawhide into a fragrant snack, encouraging picky dogs to settle down and chew; uniform 2.5-inch size fits small to medium mouths without posing the swallow-whole risk of bigger rolls.
Value for Money: At about 67¢ per roll these sit squarely between bulk rawhide chips and boutique single-ingredient chews; given 36 portions, one bag lasts most single-dog households over a month.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Pros – inexpensive oral-care activity, chicken aroma entices fussy eaters, rolls don’t stain carpets, portion-controlled size reduces overfeeding.
Cons – still contains rawhide, which can swell and cause blockages in aggressive swallowers; sourced overseas with limited transparency; stuffing can encourage dogs to gulp once the outer layer softens.
Bottom Line: Acceptable for supervised, moderate chewers who work the roll slowly. Pass if your dog is a gulper or has a sensitive gut, and always provide plenty of water.
Why Ol’ Roy Still Matters in 2025’s Treat Aisle
Loyal Walmart Shopper Demand
More households than ever are one-stop shopping at Walmart for groceries, prescriptions, and pet supplies. That foot traffic keeps Ol’ Roy’s price point razor-thin and forces constant SKU innovation—meaning new flavors and functional claims appear faster than premium brands can match.
Macro-Economic Pressure on Pet Parents
Inflation continues to outpace wage growth, so treating accounts for a bigger slice of disposable income. Ol’ Roy’s sub-$5 bags look increasingly attractive, but only if safety transparency keeps pace.
How Ol’ Roy Prices Stay Low Without Sacrificing Safety
Vertical Supply Chain Leverage
Walmart negotiates ingredient contracts on a global scale, locking in grains and proteins at commodity prices months in advance. This allows Ol’ Roy to buffer market spikes that boutique brands absorb at a premium.
Streamlined SKUs
Fewer specialty shapes, dye colors, and “limited ingredient” variants mean equipment runs longer with fewer costly change-overs—savings that roll downhill to shelf stickers.
Decoding the 2025 Label: Nutritional Adequacy & Feeding Directions
AAFCO Statement Location
Treats aren’t required to be complete and balanced, but Ol’ Roy now prints an optional AAFCO statement on several lines. Spotting the wording “formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for adult maintenance” tells you the treat can supply more than empty calories.
Calorie Disclosure Format
New FDA labeling rules mandate kilocalories per treat in a font at least 75% the size of the net weight—handy for small-breed owners counting every kcal.
Ingredient Red Flags That Override a Bargain Price
Generic “Meat and Bone Meal” Sourcing
unnamed species means potential allergen rotation headaches or ethical discomfort; look for specific proteins like chicken meal or beef meal.
Artificial Preservatives Under Scrutiny
BHA, BHT, and TBHQ remain legal but face intensifying consumer pressure; if your dog eats multiple treats daily, cumulative exposure may add up.
Grain-Inclusive vs. Grain-Free: What Science Says in 2025
FDA Dilated Cardiomyopathy Investigation Update
With peas and potatoes still flagged in ongoing DCM research, Ol’ Roy’s traditional wheat/corn/oat bases may actually reassure veterinarians—provided your dog doesn’t have a verified grain allergy.
Fiber Equivalence
Grain-inclusive biscuits often beat grain-free tubers on satiety; a fuller dog is less likely to over-eat expensive calories elsewhere.
Reading Between the Guaranteed Analysis Lines
Minimum Protein vs. Biological Value
Crude protein percentage omits amino-acid score; chicken-first recipes generally deliver better muscle-building blocks than corn-gluten-heavy formulas, even at identical protein percents.
Fat Satiation Factor
Dogs self-regulate intake partly on fat aroma; a 7%-fat biscuit may reduce begging better than a 4%-fat one, saving you extra treats (and dollars) long term.
Functional Ingredients Worth Paying Extra For
Glucosamine & Chondroitin Levels
Look for ppm (parts per million) rather than vague “contains” phrasing; effective joint support starts around 300 mg glucosamine per 20 lb body weight daily.
Omega-3 Fatty Acid Ratios
EPA/DHA inclusion supports skin, coat, and cognition—especially important for senior rescues on a budget.
Caloric Density Mistakes That Pack On Pounds
“Just One More” Trap
A 30-lb dog needs only 22–25 kcal per pound of body weight per day; at 40 kcal each, two large biscuits equal an entire meal for small breeds.
Treat Allocation Rule of Thumb
Veterinary nutritionists advise ≤10% of daily calories from treats—use your dog’s food bag kcal/kg math to pre-portion a weekly “allowance” jar.
Allergen Management: Peas, Chicken, and Beyond
Rotation Diets
If your pup itches but tests are inconclusive, rotate single-protein Ol’ Roy lines every eight weeks; cheaper price means you can trial without breaking the bank.
Hydrolyzed Protein Rumors
Ol’ Roy doesn’t yet use true hydrolysates; for severe IBD dogs, budget for veterinary therapeutic treats instead.
Hard Biscuits, Soft Chews, or Jerky Strips: Texture Considerations
Dental Health Angles
Crunchy biscuits can reduce tartar by up to 15% when fed daily, according to VOHC-adjacent studies—still brush, but think of them as floss-lite.
Senior Dog Palatability
Soft chews microwave well; 5 s on low power revives aroma without cooking nutrients, useful for picky geriatrics.
Safety Recalls & Quality Control: 2024 Post-Mortem
Salmonella Scare Frequency
Ol’ Roy’s last voluntary recall was 2022; Walmart now mandates finished-product pathogen screening before warehouse release, slashing lot contamination risk.
Supply Chain Mapping
Third-party audits expanded to Tier-2 ingredient suppliers—ask customer service for a lot-specific “pedigree sheet” if you want transparency.
Sustainability & Ethical Sourcing Questions Answered
Rendering Plant Traceability
Ol’ Roy shares rendering facility codes; cross-check against EPA violation databases for extra peace of mind.
Packaging Footprint
Shift from multi-layer plastic pouches to #4 recyclable bags in 2025 cut overall plastic by 28%, pushing Ol’ Roy ahead of some mid-tier brands.
Transitioning Treats Without Triggering Tummy Chaos
7-Day Blend Rule
Substitute 25% new treats every two days; abrupt changes on budget brands can overwhelm dogs with higher fiber loads.
Probiotic Insurance
A daily canine-specific probiotic blunts loose-stool risk during pantry swaps, costing pennies compared to a vet visit.
Wallet Hacks: Coupons, Cashback, and Auto-Delivery in 2025
Walmart+ In-App Perks
Members unlock “pet care” cashback rotating quarterly—pair with Ibotta for double-dips reaching 15% net savings.
Price-Per-Ounce Calculation
Shelf tags now print unit pricing, but compare after coupon discounts; a 36-oz “value” bag at 25% off often beats a 72-oz club pack at full price.
Vet Checkpoints: When Generic Treats Aren’t Enough
Chronic Kidney Disease Phosphorus Caps
Prescription renal treats stay under 0.5% phosphorus on DMB—Ol’ Roy hovers near 1%. Switch if labs trend upward.
Pancreatitis History
Fat ceiling is 7% DM for most veterinary diets; Ol’ Roy’s jerky variants can hit 18%. Skip or severely portion.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Are Ol’ Roy dog treats safe in 2025 after past recalls?
Yes—post-2022 supply-chain tightening and pathogen pre-screening mean current lots meet or exceed industry Salmonella standards. -
How do I store budget treats to keep them fresh?
Seal the original bag inside an airtight container; add a tablespoon of dry white rice as a food-safe desiccant to control moisture without chemicals. -
Is feeding only Ol’ Roy treats harmful long-term?
Not if total daily treat calories stay ≤10% of your dog’s diet and the chosen variety carries an AAFCO statement for nutritional adequacy. -
Can puppies eat Ol’ Roy biscuits?
Opt for puppy-labeled soft chews or break large biscuits into puppy-thumb-sized pieces to avoid choking until 6 months of age. -
What’s the biggest nutritional gap in Ol’ Roy treats?
Omega-3 fatty acids are typically low; supplement with fish-body oil or rotate in a marine-protein treat twice a week. -
Do grain-inclusive Ol’ Roy treats cause allergies?
True grain allergies affect <1% of dogs—most itchiness stems from beef, dairy, or chicken. Trial elimination before blaming corn or wheat. -
How can I verify a lot number if my dog gets sick?
Photograph the bag’s bottom stamp and email Walmart customer service; they’ll release third-party lab results for that specific batch within 48 hours. -
Are dye-free versions worth the extra 20 cents?
If your dog has demonstrated food-sensitivity hypersensitivity or you want to avoid unnecessary additives, the small upcharge pays for itself in peace of mind. -
Can I bake homemade treats cheaper than Ol’ Roy?
ingredient inflation often pushes DIY costs above $3/lb—Ol’ Roy’s economies of scale edge out most home kitchens unless you already buy bulk meat. -
What’s the quickest way to confirm calories per treat?
Use Walmart’s app scanner—updated 2025 labels now show exact kcal under “nutritional info,” sparing you math at the shelf.